Average score
Product 1: Level Lock+ Smart Lock
3.7
Product 2: Yale August Smart Lock
4.2
Access logs
Product 1: Level Lock+ Smart Lock
3.9

Activity logging is available and useful for seeing who unlocked and when, but some reviewers want more detail and better accuracy, and at least one notes that logs can be more accessible when you are within Bluetooth range.

Product 2: Yale August Smart Lock
3.9

Activity and access logs are generally presented as a clear timeline of lock events and users, but one negative review claims a late-night unlock incident did not appear in the log, raising consistency concerns in edge cases.

Alarm/siren loudness (if included)
Product 1: Level Lock+ Smart Lock
3.3

Sound feedback is polarizing: the lock offers volume controls, but multiple reviewers still find the lowest setting too loud and wish silence or finer-grained control were available without relying on the Level app.

Product 2: Yale August Smart Lock
No score yet
App
Product 1: Level Lock+ Smart Lock
4.0

The Level app is generally seen as capable for setup, sharing, passes, and tuning settings like sound and range, but several reviews note quirks (e.g., firmware update progress) and many Apple-first users rely more on the Home app day to day.

Product 2: Yale August Smart Lock
4.0

The app is generally described as intuitive and full-featured (status view, settings, guest management, alerts, and timelines), though one highly negative review reports freezing, connectivity frustration, and inconsistent state reporting.

Auto-lock
Product 1: Level Lock+ Smart Lock
3.9

Auto-lock works as a time-based setting and is generally seen as useful, but reviewers note it cannot confirm the door is actually closed. Some users compensate with Home automations using a separate door sensor. Auto-unlock exists but is treated as more finicky than Home Key, because it relies on Bluetooth plus location logic and often requires leaving the geofence boundary before it will re-arm. Several reviewers prefer NFC/Home Key for intentional, predictable entry.

Product 2: Yale August Smart Lock
4.5

Auto-lock is consistently praised for flexibility (from very short delays up to about 30 minutes) and for preventing accidentally-unlocked doors, but some users disable it to avoid being locked out when they step outside without phone or keys. Auto-unlock is a high-convenience feature when it behaves, but experiences vary: some reviews say it works well most of the time, while long-term users report it can be slow, inconsistent, or unreliable enough to fall back to physical keys.

Backset compatibility
Product 1: Level Lock+ Smart Lock
4.1

Backset support is geared toward common standards (2-3/8 and 2-3/4 inches), with included parts like bolt extenders/long caps noted as helpful when adapting to typical door setups.

Product 2: Yale August Smart Lock
No score yet
Battery
Product 1: Level Lock+ Smart Lock
3.7

Battery design (CR2 hidden in the bolt) is widely praised for tool-free access and simplicity, with typical life estimates around six months. The most common complaint is the app reporting being too coarse (no percentage), making planning replacements harder.

Product 2: Yale August Smart Lock
3.1

Battery life is the most common tradeoff: the lock uses two CR123 batteries, and while some sources cite multi-month expectations, at least one long-term review reports significantly shorter life (weeks) and others note higher replacement cost and limited in-app visibility.

Bluetooth
Product 1: Level Lock+ Smart Lock
3.6

Bluetooth is central for local operation and some features, but it draws mixed feedback: some reviewers find it stable, while others call it temperamental and prefer Thread-class reliability. A boost-range option can help at the cost of battery life.

Product 2: Yale August Smart Lock
3.6

Bluetooth is used for close-range control and proximity-based features (including aspects of auto-unlock), and while it works well for many, some users describe occasional slow or inconsistent proximity behavior.

Build quality and durability
Product 1: Level Lock+ Smart Lock
4.3

Build quality is consistently described as premium and discreet, with lots of metal and very little visible bulk. Multiple reviewers cite robust ratings/standards and generally trust the hardware durability once properly aligned.

Product 2: Yale August Smart Lock
4.4

Build quality impressions are strong: the compact puck design is described as well-made with a good feel and improved aesthetics compared with older, bulkier generations.

Door-sense
Product 1: Level Lock+ Smart Lock
2.3

Door-sense is a notable omission: multiple reviewers explicitly wish the lock could detect when the door is closed to make auto-lock smarter and reduce mis-lock scenarios on ajar doors.

Product 2: Yale August Smart Lock
3.8

DoorSense/door-position sensing is often cited as useful and accurate for door-ajar alerts when installed and calibrated, but at least one reviewer reports persistent calibration problems and unreliable open/closed status detection.

Door compatibility (deadbolt fit)
Product 1: Level Lock+ Smart Lock
3.7

Fit is best on standard deadbolt-prepped doors that close smoothly. Several reviews stress that misalignment, shallow strike holes, or the Lock+ round bolt/battery design can cause extra tweaking on some doors.

Product 2: Yale August Smart Lock
No score yet
Existing hardware reuse
Product 1: Level Lock+ Smart Lock
3.0

This model replaces the full deadbolt, so you generally cannot reuse your existing keyed hardware the way retrofit kits can. Rekeying is possible but often framed as a locksmith job, and some reviewers note it is not a casual DIY swap.

Product 2: Yale August Smart Lock
5.0

Across reviews, the retrofit design is a standout: it replaces only the interior thumb-turn so you can keep your existing deadbolt, exterior look, and physical keys, which is especially appealing for renters and shared access situations.

Feature additions via updates
Product 1: Level Lock+ Smart Lock
3.4

Firmware and future features come up often: reviewers mention updates and the expectation of expanded Thread/Matter capabilities, but also express frustration with delays or minor app update bugs like progress reporting.

Product 2: Yale August Smart Lock
No score yet
Fingerprint
Product 1: Level Lock+ Smart Lock
1.5

Fingerprint entry is not included, and at least one reviewer flags this as a missing convenience feature compared with similarly priced competitors that bundle fingerprint readers.

Product 2: Yale August Smart Lock
No score yet
Finish durability
Product 1: Level Lock+ Smart Lock
3.5

Aesthetics are a major strength, but finish and matching hardware are mixed: some praise the available finishes while others want more color options or matching strike plates for cohesive looks.

Product 2: Yale August Smart Lock
No score yet
Geofencing
Product 1: Level Lock+ Smart Lock
3.6

Geofencing underpins auto-unlock and some touch behaviors, typically using a ~200-meter home boundary. It can work, but many reviewers note extra constraints and prefer Home Key for faster, less error-prone entry.

Product 2: Yale August Smart Lock
3.6

Geofencing underpins the arrival/leave automation and is viewed as helpful by some, but its success depends on the approach path, phone behavior, and Bluetooth handoff, leading to mixed real-world consistency.

Guest Codes and Access
Product 1: Level Lock+ Smart Lock
4.0

Guest access options include app-based invites, shareable passes, NFC cards/fobs, and keypad PINs if you add the keypad. The main downside is friction when guests must install the Level app, unless you lean on keypad/cards instead.

Product 2: Yale August Smart Lock
4.4

Guest access features are a strong point: reviews describe virtual keys, guest lists, temporary or scheduled access windows, and easy sharing (often via text/email), with keypad entry available as an add-on.

Hub requirement
Product 1: Level Lock+ Smart Lock
3.4

Hub/bridge needs are a recurring theme. Apple Home users get the cleanest remote experience with a Home hub, while non-Apple ecosystems often need Level Connect or other bridges and may still feel less complete until Thread/Matter support is fully active.

Product 2: Yale August Smart Lock
5.0

Because Wi-Fi is integrated, reviews emphasize there is no separate hub or bridge required for remote access, simplifying deployment compared with older generations that needed a plug-in module.

Installation and Setup
Product 1: Level Lock+ Smart Lock
4.3

Most reviewers found installation quick with basic tools, but doors that are tight, have nonstandard cutouts, or mismatched strike plates sometimes required sanding, drilling, or careful alignment to avoid binding.

Product 2: Yale August Smart Lock
4.2

Most reviewers describe a fast install (around 10 minutes) with clear in-app guidance and straightforward calibration, but a minority report setup friction such as app freezes, verification hassles, or door-trim/fitment tweaks that required rework.

Jam detection
Product 1: Level Lock+ Smart Lock
3.2

Jam detection/alerts appear when alignment is off or the strike-hole depth is shallow; reviewers who encountered it generally resolved the issue by adjusting the door/strike rather than blaming the motor itself.

Product 2: Yale August Smart Lock
No score yet
Key override reliability
Product 1: Level Lock+ Smart Lock
4.3

Physical keys remain a dependable fallback and are appreciated because the lock lacks external emergency power terminals. Reviewers report rarely needing the key, but value having it when batteries or connectivity fail.

Product 2: Yale August Smart Lock
4.8

Physical key override remains an important safety net: reviews repeatedly note you can still unlock with a normal key if batteries die or smart features misbehave.

Keypad
Product 1: Level Lock+ Smart Lock
3.7

There is no built-in keypad, which is a frequent tradeoff callout. An optional keypad accessory is viewed as useful and flexible to mount, but it adds cost and reduces the stealth aesthetic.

Product 2: Yale August Smart Lock
3.7

A keypad is available but typically not included; reviewers say it works and is useful for kids or key-free entry, yet it adds cost and some find it small or slightly laggy compared with locks with built-in keypads.

Keyway quality
Product 1: Level Lock+ Smart Lock
3.0

The keyway/cylinder is widely described as a standard consumer-grade core, and several reviewers criticize it for lacking higher-security pins. Upgrading or rekeying to a stronger cylinder is a common recommendation if pick resistance matters.

Product 2: Yale August Smart Lock
No score yet
Lock/unlock speed
Product 1: Level Lock+ Smart Lock
4.3

Home Key and NFC interactions are usually described as fast and near-instant, while app-based control can be slower—especially when routing through a hub for remote commands or when Bluetooth has to sync first.

Product 2: Yale August Smart Lock
4.1

Most reviews describe fast, smooth, and quiet lock/unlock action via app or manual turn, though keypad entry can have a small delay and one reviewer reports freezes that interrupt responsiveness.

Locking motor
Product 1: Level Lock+ Smart Lock
4.0

The internal motorized chassis is praised for its clean, hidden design, but it is sensitive to resistance from door alignment. When the door throws smoothly it performs well; binding can trigger jams or slower operation.

Product 2: Yale August Smart Lock
No score yet
Locking reliability
Product 1: Level Lock+ Smart Lock
4.2

Overall reliability is strong once the door and strike are aligned, with Home Key working the vast majority of the time in multiple long-term accounts. The main reliability complaints revolve around Bluetooth/geo features and mechanical binding when the door is not fully closed.

Product 2: Yale August Smart Lock
4.1

Locking reliability is rated highly in most tests after calibration, but a minority report the lock getting confused about state, inconsistent auto-unlock, or requiring occasional troubleshooting to restore dependable operation.

Notifications
Product 1: Level Lock+ Smart Lock
4.0

Notifications are commonly referenced through Apple Home (alerts when the lock is used) and through activity updates in the Level app, though detail and consistency vary depending on connectivity and which app you rely on.

Product 2: Yale August Smart Lock
4.1

Notifications and smart alerts are frequently described as timely and customizable (lock/unlock events, auto-lock events, door-ajar alerts, and user-specific actions), though one account complains about missed logging for a concerning event.

Physical attack resistance
Product 1: Level Lock+ Smart Lock
4.3

Against brute-force attacks, reviewers point to strong hardware ratings and argue the deadbolt strength is solid, with the door or frame likely failing before the bolt does in many scenarios.

Product 2: Yale August Smart Lock
4.8

One review cites top-tier physical strength (ANSI Grade 1) for the lock/bolt, framing it as unusually strong among smart locks tested.

Pick/drill resistance (if rated)
Product 1: Level Lock+ Smart Lock
2.5

Pick resistance is a consistent weak spot in the review set, with multiple references to quick picks or bump-style demonstrations using basic tools. Several reviewers recommend rekeying or upgrading the cylinder if this is a concern.

Product 2: Yale August Smart Lock
No score yet
Remote access
Product 1: Level Lock+ Smart Lock
3.9

Remote access is reliable when paired with the right hub (Apple Home hub or a Wi-Fi bridge), but without one the lock is largely a local-control device. Several reviewers highlight this as the key deciding factor beyond aesthetics.

Product 2: Yale August Smart Lock
4.4

Remote lock/unlock from anywhere is widely reported to be responsive once connected, and even the most critical reviewer notes unlocking via the app itself generally worked; issues center more on setup/state tracking than basic remote commands.

Security features (encryption)
Product 1: Level Lock+ Smart Lock
4.2

Security-wise, encryption is described positively (including end-to-end encryption mentions), and Home Key offers choices like Express Mode vs requiring device authentication, letting users balance speed and protection.

Product 2: Yale August Smart Lock
4.5

Security features discussed include encrypted connections (Bluetooth and app traffic) and safeguards like voice PIN requirements, contributing to reviewer confidence for typical smart-lock use.

Smart-home integration (Alexa, Google, Siri, HomeKit, Matter, Thread)
Product 1: Level Lock+ Smart Lock
4.4

Smart-home integration is best in Apple Home/HomeKit, where Home Key is a standout differentiator. Alexa/Google/SmartThings support is more conditional (often bridge- or version-dependent), and Thread/Matter readiness is frequently discussed as a future-proofing promise.

Product 2: Yale August Smart Lock
4.0

Smart-home integration is a core strength with support for Alexa, Google, and HomeKit (plus other ecosystems noted in reviews), though HomeKit stability and device state accuracy are not perfect for every user over time.

Two-factor authentication availability
Product 1: Level Lock+ Smart Lock
No score yet
Product 2: Yale August Smart Lock
4.5

Two-factor authentication is explicitly mentioned as available for account access, adding protection for cloud-connected control and sharing features.

User access management
Product 1: Level Lock+ Smart Lock
4.2

Access management is a strong point, with clear admin vs guest roles, time windows, recurring schedules, and revocation. Reviewers especially like the flexibility for service providers, visitors, and short-term use cases.

Product 2: Yale August Smart Lock
4.4

User access management is robust, supporting multiple users (and often multiple homes/locks), with options to tailor alerts and track who used the lock and when.

Value and Price
Product 1: Level Lock+ Smart Lock
3.4

Pricing is consistently called high (roughly $329-$349). Reviewers see the value proposition as strongest for buyers who prioritize an invisible design plus Home Key convenience, and weakest for those who want built-in keypad features or higher-security cylinders without extra cost.

Product 2: Yale August Smart Lock
3.6

Pricing is often called high but competitive for built-in Wi-Fi smart locks; many justify it for the retrofit convenience, while critics point to CR123 upkeep and occasional reliability hiccups as value detractors.

Voice control
Product 1: Level Lock+ Smart Lock
4.0

Voice control works well in Apple environments via Siri (often with confirmation) and can work with Alexa/Google depending on bridges and ecosystem choices. Several reviews caution that cross-ecosystem support is not equally mature.

Product 2: Yale August Smart Lock
3.5

Voice control works with major assistants and typically requires a PIN/password for unlocking; several reviews report good results, while others mention occasional failures, slowness, or discomfort with speaking a password aloud.

Weather resistance
Product 1: Level Lock+ Smart Lock
4.0

Weather and temperature considerations show up mainly as door-fit sensitivity (cold weather can change alignment) plus mentions of sealing details like an O-ring and broad operating temperature specs.

Product 2: Yale August Smart Lock
No score yet
Wi-Fi
Product 1: Level Lock+ Smart Lock
3.4

The lock does not include direct Wi-Fi, so remote control depends on a bridge or ecosystem hub. Reviews that used a Wi-Fi bridge generally liked the added reach, but complained about placement constraints and the one-bridge-per-lock reality in some setups.

Product 2: Yale August Smart Lock
4.1

Built-in Wi-Fi is repeatedly highlighted as the key upgrade for true remote control without an add-on bridge, but it can increase battery drain and, in one account, made setup more finicky with certain Wi-Fi environments.