Average score
P1
Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
3.3
P2
Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
3.9
Accessories and Tools
P1
Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
3.7
Tool kits are decent for the price (crevice/dusting combo, extension wand, turbo brush, sometimes an upholstery tool), but content varies by SKU and some tools are criticized for being small or not very effective.
P2
Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
4.3
It typically includes a crevice tool, dusting brush, and a pet-focused brush. The kit is useful, but a few reviewers wish a true motorized hand tool (not just a turbo-style pet brush) was included at this price.
Aesthetic design and finish
P1Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
No score yet
P2
Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
4.7
A lot of reviewers like the premium look, especially the silver/rose‑gold accents. It’s often described as more stylish than typical utilitarian uprights.
Airflow blowback
P1
Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
4.2
Blowback/scatter control is described positively in some marketing-style commentary and in bare-floor sealing discussions, but performance varies by model and floorhead seal quality.
P2
Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
2.6
Several reviews note strong, sometimes warm exhaust airflow that can blow light items (papers) around. It’s treated as an annoyance and a common ‘upright pain point’ tradeoff for high airflow.
Area Rug Handling
P1
Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
3.8
Rug handling is mixed: several reviewers like the cleaning, but some say it can feel hard to push or can lose effective contact depending on the height setting and rug thickness.
P2
Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
4.7
Area rugs and thick carpet settings are included, and most reviewers describe smooth movement and strong pickup. Lift‑Away mode on carpet can feel less controlled or even ‘run away’ without the pod’s weight.
Assembly and Setup
P1
Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
2.2
Assembly experiences range from quick to frustrating. One unboxing shows awkward screw placement and parts that do not seat easily without extra fiddling.
P2Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
No score yetAutomatic shutoff for obstructions
P1Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
No score yet
P2
Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
4.3
Some reviews mention indicator lights for jams/overheating and automatic shutdown behavior when something is blocked. It can protect the motor, but can also interrupt cleaning if debris builds up behind the roller.
Bin and Bag
P1
Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
3.5
The bin is easy to remove and empty in concept, but real-world experience varies: some call it simple, while others report stiff latches or accidental release/fit issues.
P2
Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
4.0
The bagless bin (often cited around 1 qt.) is considered ample and easy to remove/empty. Some note the bin opening can be narrow, letting hair/dust cling and occasionally requiring extra cleanup.
Build quality and durability
P1
Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
4.0
Build quality is often described as better than expected for the price, with thicker plastics and a sturdier feel, though fit/finish issues show up in some assembly/handle reports.
P2
Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
3.2
Several reviewers praise a more premium feel than budget Sharks. The biggest durability concern raised is the floorhead/nozzle: one technician calls it failure-prone and non-serviceable, while others don’t report failures in testing windows.
Carpet — High-Pile Pickup
P1
Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
2.5
High-pile carpet results are inconsistent across sources; one review suggests pet hair can be collected but general debris pickup may lag behind stronger competitors.
P2
Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
4.3
High‑pile carpet pickup is rated top-tier by most reviewers, including for cereal and pet hair. A technician review reports weak fine-sand removal on carpet and warns that leaving grit behind could wear fibers over time.
Carpet — Low-Pile Pickup
P1
Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
3.8
Low-pile carpet pickup is generally rated good to very good in the hands-on reviews, though one lab-style review found weak overall debris pickup despite decent pet-hair results.
P2
Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
4.3
Low‑pile carpet performance is consistently excellent in most standardized tests, even with cereal and fine debris. One technician review reports the opposite on carpet fine sand, suggesting results can vary with debris type and floorhead behavior.
Carpet — Medium-Pile Pickup
P1
Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
3.6
On medium-pile carpets and typical rugs, reviewers report solid cleaning but note that height settings can be finicky, sometimes reducing brush contact and requiring a re-pass.
P2
Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
4.3
Across standardized testing and mainstream reviews, medium/standard carpet pickup is excellent with few repeat passes needed. A technician review strongly disagrees, reporting poor fine-sand pickup on carpet and scattered debris.
Clogging and debris prevention
P1
Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
2.7
Clogging is most often mentioned around the turbo tool and narrow passages, especially with pet hair. Keeping the brush/tool path clear is a recurring recommendation.
P2
Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
3.0
The DuoClean head can collect debris behind the front soft roller; some users report the vacuum shutting off until it’s cleared. Regular roller/airpath checks reduce interruptions.
Comparative performance
P1
Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
1.8
Comparisons are split: one review ranks it as a low performer versus other sub-$200 uprights, while other reviewers say it is a notable step up from older Dirt Devil models but still not best-in-class versus brands like Bissell.
P2
Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
4.5
In comparisons, it’s often positioned as an upgrade over the Shark Apex and only slightly behind newer flagships like the Stratos. Multi-vac test roundups typically place it near the top tier.
Controls and UI
P1
Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
3.6
Controls are mostly simple (power, height settings, and in some versions brush or floor-mode controls). The main complaint is less about the buttons and more about how settings translate to real contact/performance.
P2
Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
4.5
Handle-mounted controls (floor-type slider and main buttons) are generally described as intuitive and easy to reach. A few comments mention needing firm presses or a learning curve with releases.
Cord length
P1
Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
3.5
Cord length is commonly referenced as about 25 feet. Some reviewers consider that fine for small areas, while others call it short versus 30-foot uprights.
P2
Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
4.6
The power cord is commonly cited around 29.5–30 ft (sometimes described as long reach), helping cover large rooms and staircases with fewer outlet changes. Cord length is a frequent positive callout.
Cord management
P1
Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
4.0
Cord management ranges from basic wrap hooks to models with cord rewind. Rewind versions are praised for convenience; non-rewind versions still have clips/hooks that work but feel budget.
P2Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
No score yetCrevice / Groove Pickup (Hard Floors)
P1Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
No score yet
P2
Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
4.7
Crevice/groove pickup is reported as unusually strong in at least one lab test (often finishing in a single forward pass). Tiny residue may remain in gaps depending on direction and debris type.
Cyclone performance
P1
Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
3.3
Cyclone separation is described as improved versus older models but still imperfect; one detailed review notes dust can bypass the cyclone and reach filters sooner than expected.
P2Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
No score yetDried-On Stain Removal
P1Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
No score yet
P2
Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
3.8
Swivel steering and a “gliding” feel on carpet are commonly praised. Tradeoffs include noticeable weight, some resistance when pulling backward on carpet, and one critique that the vacuum can ‘walk’ forward due to roller contact.
Ease of use
P1
Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
3.8
Ease of use is generally good once set up, with simple controls and straightforward mode changes. A few owners cite annoyances like finicky height settings or awkward latches.
P2
Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
4.1
Overall ease of use is good in routine vacuuming, and controls are straightforward. Usability complaints cluster around the heavy/bulky feel, Lift‑Away fatigue, and stubborn attachments that make mode/tool switching less pleasant.
Edge and Baseboard Cleaning (Hard Floors)
P1Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
No score yet
P2
Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
4.6
Edge pickup is repeatedly described as very strong, with good baseboard performance. A couple notes suggest corners can be slightly less perfect than straight edges.
Emptying and Mess Control
P1
Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
3.5
Emptying is generally straightforward, but several reviews mention mess potential (dirty bottom hatch, stiff doors, or awkward re-seating) depending on the model.
P2
Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
4.0
Emptying is generally easy via a bottom-release door, and the clear bin helps monitor fill level. Because it’s bagless, dust/hair can cling inside and emptying can release allergens if done indoors.
Filtration / Dust Containment
P1
Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
3.4
Filtration is typically described as average for an unsealed bagless upright. Some reviewers note the lack of a true HEPA-style seal and report dust reaching filters/motor-side areas.
P2
Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
4.7
Anti-Allergen Complete Seal + HEPA filtration is repeatedly highlighted as a major strength for allergy-sensitive homes. Bagless emptying still requires care to avoid dust plumes, and filters need routine cleaning/replacement.
Floorhead design
P1
Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
3.2
The floorhead/brush system is aggressive and carpet-focused. Reviewers mention stiff bristles, felt strips, and height setting quirks that can affect contact and ease of pushing.
P2
Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
3.8
The DuoClean PowerFins floorhead is central to its strong surface pickup and helps prevent ‘snowplowing’ on hard floors. Downsides mentioned include debris getting trapped behind the front roller and one technician calling the nozzle design inefficient—especially for fine debris on carpet.
Floorhead Seal on Hard Floors
P1
Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
4.1
At least one review highlights better sealing on hard floors that reduces debris spit-out, but others describe limited sealing and less controlled bare-floor behavior.
P2
Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
3.8
At least one technical review credits the rear squeegee/brush elements with helping create a good seal on hard floors for effective suction. This supports the strong hard-floor results seen in other tests.
Hair Pickup — Carpets
P1
Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
3.3
Carpet hair pickup is a relative strength in several reviews, especially for a lower-cost upright, though performance varies by model and test method.
P2
Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
4.3
Pet-hair pickup on carpet is near-perfect in several test suites. A dissenting technician review shows some hair remaining or getting worked into carpet during fine-debris scenarios.
Hair Pickup — Hard Floors
P1
Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
1.5
Hard-floor hair pickup is less consistent, particularly if the brush is disabled or the head does not seal well; some users still report acceptable results on bare floors.
P2Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
No score yetHair‑Wrap / Tangle Resistance
P1
Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
2.0
Hair-wrap resistance is average at best. Multiple reviewers mention hair wrapping around the brushroll and needing periodic cleaning.
P2
Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
4.4
Most reviewers praise the self-cleaning/anti-wrap brushroll and PowerFins for resisting tangles, even with long hair. One technician review disputes this, saying hair can wrap or stick under the roller when airflow to the front roller is limited.
Hard Floor — Fine Dust Pickup
P1
Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
3.5
Fine dust on hard floors is described as acceptable when the head is set correctly, but overall hard-floor refinement varies and depends heavily on the specific model/SKU discussed.
P2
Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
4.5
Multiple test-based reviews report excellent fine-debris pickup on hard floors (e.g., flour/sugar), including in cracks when approached correctly. A technician review reports some scattering and questions how much the front roller contributes, so technique and debris type may matter.
Hard Floor — Large Debris Intake
P1
Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
3.4
Large debris intake on hard floors ranges from poor to good. One review reports weak pickup of larger pieces, while another notes a bare-floor setup/seal that helps prevent blowback.
P2
Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
4.6
Large-debris pickup on hard floors is a standout: reviewers praise DuoClean for pulling in rice/oats/cereal without pushing it around. Most tests show fast cleanup in just a couple passes.
Headlight and LED lights
P1Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
No score yet
P2
Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
4.6
The bright LED headlights on the floorhead are consistently praised for improving visibility along edges and under furniture. They’re viewed as a must-have at this price and the Vertex delivers.
Hose length
P1
Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
3.8
Hose reach is described as usable to solid for above-floor tasks, with some reviewers satisfied for stairs and furniture, though exact length varies across versions mentioned.
P2
Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
3.6
The hose is often listed around 5.5 ft and is adequate for many stair and above-floor tasks. Some reviewers still wish it were longer, and one technician critic describes it as very short in practice.
Low-profile design
P1
Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
2.4
Low-profile reach is limited in at least one unboxing, with the body/cyclone area preventing the head from getting truly flat. Under-furniture access depends on clearance and the specific model shape.
P2Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
No score yetMaintenance requirements
P1
Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
3.2
Maintenance is routine for a bagless upright: regular filter washing and brush/hose checks. Some designs make brush access or tool cleaning more tedious than expected.
P2
Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
3.6
Maintenance typically involves washing pre-motor filters, keeping rollers clean, and periodic HEPA care. Some call it easy with washable filters; others emphasize it gets dirty and needs regular attention—especially around the soft roller and filters.
Maneuverability and Handling
P1
Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
3.6
Handling is decent for a non-swivel budget upright, but some users report it can feel hard to push on thicker rugs and does not match premium maneuverability.
P2Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
No score yetNoise level
P1
Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
3.2
Noise is described as typical to loud for a corded upright. The turbo tool is singled out as especially loud in one review.
P2
Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
3.9
Noise readings are generally in the mid‑70 dB range for a high-performance upright, with most calling it tolerable. A technician review notes a high‑pitched tone, even if it’s quieter than older Sharks.
Onboard tool storage
P1
Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
4.1
Onboard storage is a plus in several reviews, with dedicated spots/posts for tools. Some note wasted space or a storage position for a tool that is not included.
P2
Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
3.2
Onboard storage is limited: multiple reviews note only two of the three tools store on the machine, and stored tools can be knocked off. Many owners will need separate storage for the extra accessory.
Ongoing ownership costs (bags, filters, batteries)
P1Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
No score yet
P2
Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
1.8
You avoid recurring bag purchases, but ongoing costs can include filter replacement and, potentially, floorhead/nozzle parts. A technician review suggests ownership costs can spike if major assemblies need replacement.
Overall durability/longevity
P1
Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
3.3
Long-term longevity is uncertain. Reviewers like the improved design but caution that motors and sealing are not premium, and expectations should match the budget tier.
P2
Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
1.6
Longevity impressions are split: several reviewers frame it as a premium, well-built Shark, while a technician warns it’s effectively disposable with potentially expensive floorhead/nozzle replacements over time.
Overall opinion
P1Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
No score yet
P2
Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
4.6
Overall sentiment is strongly positive from test sites and home reviewers, often calling it a top-tier upright for cleaning and pet hair. There is a notable dissenting technician review that questions nozzle design, longevity, and overall value. Evidence: reviews.json reviews
Pet-Ready Features
P1Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
No score yet
P2
Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
4.7
Reviewers consistently call this a pet-friendly upright: strong pet-hair pickup on floors and stairs, plus anti-hair-wrap brush design. One dissenting technician review reports hair can still wrap or get stuck under the rollers in some scenarios.
Price and Value
P1
Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
3.4
Value is a common theme: strong performance for the money around the lower price point, but the proposition weakens if priced closer to higher-performing competitors.
P2
Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
3.7
It’s frequently described as expensive at full price, but many feel the cleaning performance justifies it when discounted. Value drops for buyers who prioritize light weight, low maintenance, or long-term serviceability.
Scratch resistance
P1Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
No score yet
P2
Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
3.8
One review cautions that brushrolls may still spin in hard-floor mode, which could worry owners of delicate floors. No scratches were observed in testing, but caution is advised on soft or easily marred surfaces.
Stair Cleaning
P1
Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
4.0
Stair cleaning is generally rated good when using the hose and tools; one hands-on review specifically notes reaching multiple steps without moving the unit often.
P2
Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
4.5
Powered Lift‑Away and the included tools make stairs easier than hauling a full upright, and the long cord helps cover a staircase in one go. Carrying/balancing the pod can still tire arms during longer stair sessions.
Storage footprint and upright-stand stability
P1Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
No score yet
P2
Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
3.6
It stores upright and some owners treat it as a dedicated floor-specific vacuum (e.g., “upstairs”). The overall footprint is bulky, and Lift-Away configurations can feel less stable or prone to toppling if set down.
Suction and Airflow
P1
Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
4.4
Most reviews describe strong suction and improved airflow versus older Dirt Devil uprights, with a stiff brushroll that can pull embedded debris. Performance can dip if filters clog or if the brush/head loses contact at certain height settings.
P2
Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
4.6
Most testing-focused reviews describe the Vertex as one of Shark’s strongest uprights for raw suction/airflow. One technician review measured good vacuum numbers but argues the nozzle/airpath design limits how effectively that power translates to carpet fine-debris pickup.
Support and Reliability
P1
Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
3.0
Support and reliability feedback is mixed. One source notes a multi-year limited warranty, while another warns warranty handling may be frustrating and recommends purchasing from a retailer with easy proof-of-purchase.
P2
Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
1.7
Some sources point to a strong warranty, but at least one technician review describes support as time-consuming and parts/service as inconvenient. Reliability perceptions therefore vary widely.
Surface safety with attachments
P1
Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
2.6
Surface safety is a concern on delicate hard floors in some reviews due to an always-on or aggressive brushroll and inconsistent hard-floor sealing.
P2Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
No score yetTool-change simplicity
P1
Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
2.9
Tool swapping and compatibility can be a pain point. Multiple reviewers call out a proprietary fitting, which can limit use of universal attachments.
P2
Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
3.0
Multiple reviews say the attachments use a tight, compression-fit connection—sometimes requiring twisting and feeling stuck. Tool swaps aren’t as quick or effortless as click-in systems.
Under-Furniture Pickup
P1
Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
2.3
Under-furniture pickup is often limited by the head not lying fully flat and by bulk around the cyclone/body, making it harder to reach low-clearance areas.
P2
Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
4.1
Under‑furniture reach improves dramatically in Lift‑Away mode compared with standard upright use. It still isn’t as low-profile as a canister or slim stick vacuum, and one critic says it doesn’t truly lay flat.
Upholstery / Above-Floor Pickup
P1
Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
3.4
Above-floor cleaning is helped by a usable hose and included tools, and at least one reviewer reports stair reach of roughly 9-10 steps. The turbo tool can be loud and may clog with hair.
P2
Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
4.6
Above-floor cleaning is generally strong thanks to Lift‑Away and the included tools for upholstery, dusting, and cobwebs. Limitations include the weight of the pod during extended use and hose reach for tall areas.
Versatility
P1Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
No score yet
P2
Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
4.3
Versatility is a consistent highlight: upright cleaning, Lift‑Away for stairs, and above-floor use with tools. Even reviews that dislike aspects of the design acknowledge it can be configured for many tasks.
Weight
P1
Product 1: Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
3.9
Weight is repeatedly described as manageable for an upright (mid-teens pounds in some discussions), helping with carry and room-to-room moves.
P2
Product 2: Shark Vertex Upright Vacuum with...
3.4
Weight is usually cited around 16–17 lb, which many classify as heavy for daily carries between floors. Using Lift‑Away can redistribute weight, but the pod itself can still feel substantial.