P1
Black+Decker Thermal Coffeemaker, 12-Cup CM2035B
P2
Breville Barista Touch Espresso Machine
Average score
P1
Product 1: Black+Decker Thermal Coffeemaker, 12-Cup CM2035B
4.0
P2
Product 2: Breville Barista Touch Espresso Machine
3.8
Accessories
P1Product 1: Black+Decker Thermal Coffeemaker, 12-Cup CM2035B
No score yet
P2
Product 2: Breville Barista Touch Espresso Machine
4.1
Accessories are generally treated as complete for getting started: portafilter and baskets, milk jug, tamper and a razor-style dose trimmer, plus cleaning-related items. Reviewers like that the kit supports the guided workflow without immediately requiring add-ons.
Accuracy of marketing claims
P1
Product 1: Black+Decker Thermal Coffeemaker, 12-Cup CM2035B
4.1
Marketing claims around even dispersion are generally supported by observations that the showerhead-style system wets grounds evenly. Heat retention claims also align with reports of coffee staying hot for hours in a vacuum-sealed thermal carafe.
P2
Product 2: Breville Barista Touch Espresso Machine
4.1
When reviewers address claims, they generally validate the headline convenience points like fast heat-up and a guided touchscreen workflow. The marketing criticism, when present, is more about feature omissions (like connectivity) than outright performance exaggeration.
App, connectivity and smart control
P1Product 1: Black+Decker Thermal Coffeemaker, 12-Cup CM2035B
No score yet
P2
Product 2: Breville Barista Touch Espresso Machine
1.4
Connectivity is typically described as minimal: the touchscreen is the control center, but WiFi/app features and firmware-update convenience are often cited as missing. For shoppers who want smart features, that omission is framed as a real downside.
Assembly and Setup
P1
Product 1: Black+Decker Thermal Coffeemaker, 12-Cup CM2035B
4.7
Setup is described as quick and easy, with a concise manual and the common recommendation to run initial water-only cycles before brewing coffee.
P2
Product 2: Breville Barista Touch Espresso Machine
4.7
Setup is commonly described as straightforward, with clear on-screen guidance and an approachable first-drink experience. Most reviewers treat it as easier than more manual machines, though espresso still rewards some learning.
Automation and sensors
P1
Product 1: Black+Decker Thermal Coffeemaker, 12-Cup CM2035B
4.4
Automation features are repeatedly called out as standout for the price: 24-hour programmability, auto-brew, a freshness timer (time-since-brew), brew-strength selection, and a 1-4 cup mode. Reviews also mention a descale indicator and a dedicated descale mode.
P2
Product 2: Breville Barista Touch Espresso Machine
4.7
Automation is a core selling point in the reviews: the touchscreen drink menu, guided steps, programmable drinks, and automated milk texturing reduce the skill barrier. Reviewers often describe the workflow as interactive and fast, even though tamping is still manual.
Boiler type (single vs dual)
P1Product 1: Black+Decker Thermal Coffeemaker, 12-Cup CM2035B
No score yet
P2
Product 2: Breville Barista Touch Espresso Machine
3.4
Boiler/heating-system talk consistently frames it as a fast-heating, single-system style machine rather than a true dual-boiler. Reviews highlight the tradeoff: quick readiness and simpler daily flow, but no brew-and-steam-at-the-same-time workflow.
Brewing performance and consistency
P1
Product 1: Black+Decker Thermal Coffeemaker, 12-Cup CM2035B
3.9
Reviews describe the coffee as smooth, balanced, and easy-drinking, with even wetting of grounds credited to the showerhead-style dispersion. One lab test reported brew-water temperature averaging about 177.4°F, below the Specialty Coffee Association ideal extraction range, which can reduce strength and clarity versus higher-end brewers.
P2
Product 2: Breville Barista Touch Espresso Machine
4.2
Reviewers generally report repeatable shots after dial-in, helped by the guided touchscreen workflow and consistent brewing behavior. The main consistency complaints tend to revolve around the built-in grinder being stepped and the usual learning curve of espresso, not wild temperature swings.
Build quality and durability
P1
Product 1: Black+Decker Thermal Coffeemaker, 12-Cup CM2035B
3.2
Build feedback is mixed: several reviews describe lightweight or flimsy plastic components on the brewer body, while the stainless thermal carafe is often described as sturdy and durable.
P2
Product 2: Breville Barista Touch Espresso Machine
4.0
Build quality is usually characterized as solid and premium-looking, with stainless elements and a well-finished feel. A minority of comments caution that more automation and electronics can mean more parts that could fail over time compared with simpler models.
Capacity
P1
Product 1: Black+Decker Thermal Coffeemaker, 12-Cup CM2035B
4.8
Capacity is consistently positioned as a full 12-cup brewer with a 60-ounce thermal carafe, highlighted as a benefit compared with smaller thermal models.
P2
Product 2: Breville Barista Touch Espresso Machine
4.1
Capacity is usually portrayed as adequate for households, with reviewers mentioning a sizable rear water tank and a decent bean hopper typical of Breville all-in-ones. It supports multiple drinks without constant refills, though heavy users still refill water and empty trays regularly.
Capsules, pods and consumables
P1Product 1: Black+Decker Thermal Coffeemaker, 12-Cup CM2035B
No score yet
P2
Product 2: Breville Barista Touch Espresso Machine
2.1
Several reviews explicitly contrast the Barista Touch experience with pod systems like Nespresso. The consistent takeaway is that this machine is for beans and grounds and a more hands-on espresso hobby, not capsule convenience.
Cup, tray and carafe handling
P1
Product 1: Black+Decker Thermal Coffeemaker, 12-Cup CM2035B
4.0
The thermal, vacuum-sealed carafe is praised for keeping coffee hot for hours and having a wide mouth that is easier to clean. Downsides include press-to-pour ergonomics for smaller hands and cautionary notes about not pulling the lid by the lever.
P2
Product 2: Breville Barista Touch Espresso Machine
4.1
Cup and tray handling feedback centers on practical usability: the drip tray is easy to remove and clean, and there is generally enough clearance for common cups. Some reviews note typical Breville-style drip tray filling and the need to empty it regularly.
Design, ergonomics and footprint
P1
Product 1: Black+Decker Thermal Coffeemaker, 12-Cup CM2035B
4.4
Multiple reviews emphasize a compact footprint for a 12-cup machine and a straightforward front-facing control panel. Measurements cited include a small counter footprint (around 7 by 9 inches in one write-up) and dimensions around 9.5 x 8 x 13 inches in another.
P2
Product 2: Breville Barista Touch Espresso Machine
4.4
Reviews frequently praise the overall design and counter appeal, with the touchscreen being a central ergonomic feature. The footprint is generally described as manageable for an all-in-one espresso station, with notes that it fits under many cabinets better than taller competitors.
Design flaws
P1
Product 1: Black+Decker Thermal Coffeemaker, 12-Cup CM2035B
3.2
Common drawbacks across reviews include below-ideal brew-water temperature for stronger extraction, a press-to-pour carafe that can be awkward, a fixed reservoir, and notes that brew time can feel long for some users.
P2
Product 2: Breville Barista Touch Espresso Machine
3.1
Commonly cited downsides include the lack of WiFi/app-style updates in touchscreen models, the manual tamp step, and typical quirks like drip tray management or keeping sensors clean. Most reviews frame these as livable tradeoffs rather than fatal flaws.
Espresso and beverage quality
P1Product 1: Black+Decker Thermal Coffeemaker, 12-Cup CM2035B
No score yet
P2
Product 2: Breville Barista Touch Espresso Machine
4.4
Across the reviews, the Barista Touch is described as capable of producing genuinely cafe-style espresso and milk drinks once it is dialed in, with good flavor and crema for a mid-range all-in-one machine. Results depend on grind, dose, and puck prep, but most reviewers are happy with the drink quality for everyday home use.
Filter
P1
Product 1: Black+Decker Thermal Coffeemaker, 12-Cup CM2035B
3.6
It uses standard basket-style paper filters and does not include a permanent filter. This simplifies daily cleanup for some reviewers but adds ongoing cost and waste for others.
P2
Product 2: Breville Barista Touch Espresso Machine
4.1
When a water filter is mentioned, it is typically framed as a welcome inclusion that helps with taste and scaling management. Reviews treat it as part of the broader maintenance story rather than a standout differentiator.
Grinder, hopper and dosing system
P1Product 1: Black+Decker Thermal Coffeemaker, 12-Cup CM2035B
No score yet
P2
Product 2: Breville Barista Touch Espresso Machine
3.9
The integrated grinder is widely treated as a real convenience, with reviewers noting stepped adjustments and a workable range for dialing in espresso. Tradeoffs mentioned include the limits of an all-in-one grinder (retention, static or clumping depending on beans) and that perfectionists may still prefer a separate grinder.
Guided tamper convenience
P1Product 1: Black+Decker Thermal Coffeemaker, 12-Cup CM2035B
No score yet
P2
Product 2: Breville Barista Touch Espresso Machine
2.5
In comparisons, reviewers often point out that assisted tamping is a feature of Touch Impress or Oracle-style machines, not the standard Barista Touch. For this product, tamping is described as manual, which keeps engagement high but removes some of the foolproofing beginners might want.
Heating-element power
P1Product 1: Black+Decker Thermal Coffeemaker, 12-Cup CM2035B
No score yet
P2
Product 2: Breville Barista Touch Espresso Machine
4.8
Heating performance is repeatedly praised, especially in connection with ThermoJet-style fast readiness. Reviewers frame the system as strong for quick brewing and convenient daily use, even if it does not replicate the simultaneous brew-and-steam advantages of higher-end dual-boiler platforms.
Iced / cold-brew function quality
P1Product 1: Black+Decker Thermal Coffeemaker, 12-Cup CM2035B
No score yet
P2
Product 2: Breville Barista Touch Espresso Machine
3.7
A few reviews talk about iced drinks mainly as espresso poured over ice rather than a true cold-brew system. When cold extraction is mentioned, it is usually in the context of Touch Impress variants, not the standard Barista Touch.
Mess-free used-puck disposal
P1Product 1: Black+Decker Thermal Coffeemaker, 12-Cup CM2035B
No score yet
P2
Product 2: Breville Barista Touch Espresso Machine
3.6
Used-puck handling is described as standard for a semi-automatic: it works fine with a knock box, but it is not a dedicated mess-free system. A few reviewers mention typical countertop mess from grinding or puck prep rather than anything unique to the machine.
Milk, steam and frothing
P1Product 1: Black+Decker Thermal Coffeemaker, 12-Cup CM2035B
No score yet
P2
Product 2: Breville Barista Touch Espresso Machine
4.6
Milk performance is a major positive: reviewers emphasize the automatic milk texturing with adjustable temperature and foam, and many call it beginner-friendly for getting repeatable microfoam. The tradeoff is that it is not a dual-boiler power-steaming setup, so workflow and steam strength are framed as very good but not cafe-commercial.
Overall user experience
P1
Product 1: Black+Decker Thermal Coffeemaker, 12-Cup CM2035B
4.3
Overall usability is rated positively: intuitive buttons, clear display, and helpful features like Sneak-a-Cup pause and freshness timing. Minor friction points include the fixed reservoir for some users and the carafe pour mechanism.
P2
Product 2: Breville Barista Touch Espresso Machine
4.9
Overall user experience is described as one of the best reasons to buy: the touchscreen reduces confusion, the workflow is guided, and automated milk lowers the skill ceiling for daily lattes and cappuccinos. Multiple reviewers position it as a friendly step up from pods without the intimidation of fully manual setups.
Popularity
P1Product 1: Black+Decker Thermal Coffeemaker, 12-Cup CM2035B
No score yet
P2
Product 2: Breville Barista Touch Espresso Machine
4.7
A few reviews explicitly call the Barista Touch line best-selling or broadly popular among integrated-grinder espresso machines. Popularity is used mainly as social proof rather than a technical argument.
Pot function
P1Product 1: Black+Decker Thermal Coffeemaker, 12-Cup CM2035B
No score yet
P2
Product 2: Breville Barista Touch Espresso Machine
1.0
Where it comes up, reviewers make it clear this is not a pot or carafe coffee maker. If we want to brew a full carafe of drip coffee, this machine is the wrong category.
Pump pressure consistency
P1Product 1: Black+Decker Thermal Coffeemaker, 12-Cup CM2035B
No score yet
P2
Product 2: Breville Barista Touch Espresso Machine
4.2
When reviewers discuss pressure, they typically frame it as stable and appropriate for modern espresso, often mentioning 9-bar style brewing and pre-infusion. The machine is not portrayed as pressure-finicky once grind and dose are set.
Speed and time-to-cup
P1
Product 1: Black+Decker Thermal Coffeemaker, 12-Cup CM2035B
3.6
Speed is described as acceptable but not fast. A lab test recorded about 7 minutes and 6 seconds for a pot, and one user review described brewing roughly about a cup per minute, with stronger settings taking longer due to brief pause behavior.
P2
Product 2: Breville Barista Touch Espresso Machine
4.9
Speed is a standout theme: multiple reviews highlight very fast heat-up times (often described as a few seconds) thanks to the ThermoJet-style heating approach. That quick readiness makes the daily workflow feel much less fussy than traditional boilers that need long warm-up.
Value and Price
P1
Product 1: Black+Decker Thermal Coffeemaker, 12-Cup CM2035B
4.6
Value is consistently a highlight, frequently framed as a rare budget thermal-carafe option with features (freshness timer, programmability, strength settings) that are uncommon at similar prices.
P2
Product 2: Breville Barista Touch Espresso Machine
3.5
Value discussions tend to land in the middle: reviewers often call it expensive, but justify the price with the touchscreen workflow, fast heat-up, built-in grinder, and automated milk. Comparisons to cheaper Breville models usually frame the screen and auto milk as the main reasons to pay more.
Water system, maintenance and descaling
P1
Product 1: Black+Decker Thermal Coffeemaker, 12-Cup CM2035B
4.0
Maintenance notes include routine cleaning of the thermal carafe and a vinegar-based descaling cycle. Reviews mention a descale notification/mode, but also call out the fixed water reservoir as less convenient than removable tanks.
P2
Product 2: Breville Barista Touch Espresso Machine
4.1
Maintenance is repeatedly framed as approachable: on-screen prompts, backflushing and descaling guidance, and simple routines for keeping the group and steam system clean. Some reviewers warn that milk-related parts and sensors need regular wiping/rinsing to avoid misreads or buildup.