Pfeiffer is the clearest consensus standout, repeatedly praised for making Stacy’s grief vulnerable, layered, and emotionally convincing. Even the harshest reviews often treat her performance as the reason to keep...
Pros: main cast performance, suspense
Cons: world-building, language level
Pfeiffer turns Shyanne’s anger, vanity, fear, and fierce love into one of the show’s richest performances. Her expressive reactions and chemistry with Fanning receive near-universal praise, with only one critic...
Pros: episode structure, dialogue quality
Cons: plot twists, season finale quality