Average score
P1
Product 1: Ryobi 18V One+ Hand Vac
3.9
P2
Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
3.5
Accessories and Tools
P1
Product 1: Ryobi 18V One+ Hand Vac
3.6
Accessory support is better than many budget handhelds: reviewers noted a built-in crevice-style tool and a universal 1-1/4 inch nozzle that can accept common attachments; a brush accessory was recommended for car floors.
P2
Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
3.6
Accessories focus on everyday reach: an integrated crevice tool is repeatedly praised, and several reviews mention a small brush plus wet/dry pieces like a squeegee, along with a wall-mount charging base.
Aesthetic design and finish
P1
Product 1: Ryobi 18V One+ Hand Vac
4.0
Design details were viewed positively, including a comfortable grip and small touches like protective rubber pads that help prevent scratching surfaces when set down.
P2Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
No score yetAssembly and Setup
P1
Product 1: Ryobi 18V One+ Hand Vac
4.4
Setup is minimal. Reviews showed it works straight out of the box once a charged battery is inserted, with no real assembly beyond normal unboxing.
P2
Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
4.6
Setup is quick, with reviewers describing it as essentially click-together and ready to use in about a minute, plus easy mounting of the charging base if desired.
Battery and Charging
P1
Product 1: Ryobi 18V One+ Hand Vac
3.3
Runtime depends heavily on battery size and condition. On a 2Ah pack, one test ran 14:49 total with noticeable power drop around 12–13 minutes; a different reviewer cited up to about 25 minutes in ideal conditions. One charge-time test took about an hour versus a 40-minute claim, so swapping batteries is the easiest workaround.
P2
Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
3.1
Charging is handled via a wall-mount base that reviewers find convenient, but recharge times can be long (hours). It works best as an always-on-the-dock grab-and-go tool.
Bin and Bag
P1
Product 1: Ryobi 18V One+ Hand Vac
3.6
Capacity is a standout for the size: one review verified the bin holds about 2.5 cups (20 oz). However, a separate comparison observed a bit of sand regurgitation when the vacuum was jostled after pickup.
P2
Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
3.2
The bin is small and transparent for visibility, which helps for quick pickups but means more frequent emptying during bigger cleanups.
Build quality and durability
P1
Product 1: Ryobi 18V One+ Hand Vac
4.2
One reviewer’s hands-on impression was that it feels sturdy and not like cheap plastic, suggesting decent build quality for the price tier.
P2Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
No score yetCarpet — Low-Pile Pickup
P1Product 1: Ryobi 18V One+ Hand Vac
No score yet
P2
Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
3.1
On low-pile carpet and mats, performance ranges from adequate to struggling depending on the debris and how clean the filter is. Some testers report difficulty on fuzzy car carpeting and entry mats.
Clogging and debris prevention
P1Product 1: Ryobi 18V One+ Hand Vac
No score yet
P2
Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
3.4
Clogging is not a frequent theme, but some testers report larger bits can wedge in the intake and that dirty filters quickly reduce airflow, which can feel like a clog.
Controls and UI
P1
Product 1: Ryobi 18V One+ Hand Vac
4.6
Controls are simple and intuitive, centered on a basic on/off switch with no complicated modes.
P2
Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
2.8
Controls are simple but polarizing: multiple reviews note the trigger-style operation requires holding the button the entire time rather than using a constant-on switch.
Cordless convenience
P1
Product 1: Ryobi 18V One+ Hand Vac
4.4
The One+ ecosystem is the main convenience win: it is cordless and lets you swap Ryobi batteries mid-clean, which matters because performance can fade late in the pack.
P2
Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
4.3
Cordless convenience is a major upside: reviewers like being able to grab it quickly for crumbs and small messes without dealing with cords.
Crevice / Groove Pickup (Hard Floors)
P1
Product 1: Ryobi 18V One+ Hand Vac
3.8
In a standardized crevice test with sand, it cleaned the slot in roughly 35 seconds and performed strongly overall, though the very top performers in the comparison were faster.
P2
Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
3.1
Crevice work is helped by the integrated crevice tool. It can pull grit from tight seams, but reach and sealing in very tight spaces varies by tester and body shape can limit depth under low clearance.
Ease of use
P1
Product 1: Ryobi 18V One+ Hand Vac
4.5
Ease of use is a consistent positive: compact handling, simple disassembly, and straightforward operation make it well suited for quick spot cleaning and cars.
P2
Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
3.8
Ease of use is generally good for quick jobs thanks to its light weight and simple design, but frequent filter cleaning and short runtime can interrupt longer tasks.
Emptying and Mess Control
P1
Product 1: Ryobi 18V One+ Hand Vac
3.5
The bin detaches with a button and is generally straightforward to dump. Fine debris retention is not perfect in all situations, with one test showing minor leakage/regurgitation after pickup.
P2
Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
3.2
Emptying can be messy in practice: some debris sticks near the intake and several reviews describe having to remove the filter by hand. A comparative test also suggests it can hold onto collected sand well when powered off.
Filtration / Dust Containment
P1
Product 1: Ryobi 18V One+ Hand Vac
3.5
Filtration is serviceable and maintenance-friendly: reviewers described washable filters and noted that a HEPA filter upgrade is available. Dust containment for very fine sand may depend on how well the bin flap seals, since one comparison showed minor leakage.
P2
Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
3.3
Filtration is basic but washable. Reviewers say performance depends on keeping the filter and inserts clean; when they get gummed up, suction drops quickly.
Fresh Liquid Pickup Speed
P1Product 1: Ryobi 18V One+ Hand Vac
No score yet
P2
Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
4.3
Thin liquid pickup is a strong point when using the wet/dry accessory, quickly removing puddles and many mixed spills. Very viscous messes like ketchup or honey may smear and need follow-up wiping.
Hard Floor — Fine Dust Pickup
P1Product 1: Ryobi 18V One+ Hand Vac
No score yet
P2
Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
4.0
Fine dust pickup is reported as strong on hard surfaces in hands-on testing (for example flour and dust), though some budget-focused tests still note a lingering film that takes extra passes.
Hard Floor — Large Debris Intake
P1Product 1: Ryobi 18V One+ Hand Vac
No score yet
P2
Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
3.8
Large debris pickup is generally good for a handheld, with reviewers successfully grabbing crumbs, cereal, and small yard debris, though very bulky pieces can get awkward at the nozzle.
Kid-friendliness
P1
Product 1: Ryobi 18V One+ Hand Vac
4.2
A reviewer demonstrated that kids can operate it and even enjoy helping, but they also emphasized adult supervision since it is still a powered tool.
P2Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
No score yetMaintenance requirements
P1
Product 1: Ryobi 18V One+ Hand Vac
4.2
Maintenance is straightforward: filters can be removed and washed (then dried) and parts detach easily for cleaning, with an optional HEPA upgrade for finer dust.
P2
Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
2.6
Maintenance is regular and hands-on: expect frequent rinsing of the bin area and washing the filter/foam components, especially after wet pickups or fine dust.
Noise level
P1
Product 1: Ryobi 18V One+ Hand Vac
2.3
Noise is a recurring complaint. Measurements ranged from about 85 dB at arm’s length in one test to roughly 93–94 dB in a separate comparison, and reviewers repeatedly called it loud.
P2
Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
1.8
Noise is a common complaint. Testers describe it as loud for a handheld, with measured readings in the mid-70 dB range in one review and around 90 dB in a comparative test.
Ongoing ownership costs (bags, filters, batteries)
P1
Product 1: Ryobi 18V One+ Hand Vac
3.6
Longer sessions may push you toward extra batteries or higher-capacity packs, and some users may also opt for HEPA filters. Those add-ons can raise the total cost beyond the attractive tool-only price.
P2Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
No score yetPet-Ready Features
P1Product 1: Ryobi 18V One+ Hand Vac
No score yet
P2
Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
2.8
Pet readiness is mixed: it can lift loose clumps of hair and some strands, but without a roller brush it is not a specialist tool for embedded pet hair on upholstery.
Price and Value
P1
Product 1: Ryobi 18V One+ Hand Vac
3.9
Value is best for existing Ryobi owners. Reviewers cited roughly $29.97–$35 for the tool-only vacuum and about $79.97 for a kit with battery/charger; buying into the battery ecosystem just for this tool makes it feel much less economical.
P2
Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
4.2
Value is viewed positively because it is often priced in the budget range and still useful for frequent quick cleanups. The biggest value caveat is the short runtime and the need for frequent cleaning.
Runtime
P1Product 1: Ryobi 18V One+ Hand Vac
No score yet
P2
Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
2.6
Runtime is short, commonly reported around 10–11 minutes, with some testers noticing reduced power near the end of the cycle.
Storage footprint and upright-stand stability
P1
Product 1: Ryobi 18V One+ Hand Vac
4.0
Storage is convenient for a handheld: a keyhole slot allows wall hanging, and rubber pads help it rest on surfaces without sliding or scuffing.
P2
Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
4.5
Storage is a standout. The unit is compact, can live on its wall-mount dock, and is easy to stash in small homes, closets, or vehicles.
Suction and Airflow
P1
Product 1: Ryobi 18V One+ Hand Vac
4.1
Across reviews, suction is consistently described as strong for a compact cordless handheld. One comparison measured about 24 inches of water and roughly 36 CFM and showed near-complete flour removal from an entry mat plus solid crevice-sand pickup.
P2
Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
3.4
Suction is a strength for quick debris and spot cleaning, but lab-style comparisons show lower lift than pricier tool-battery handhelds and performance can drop when filters clog. It tends to handle small debris well, while bigger items may require repositioning.
Support and Reliability
P1
Product 1: Ryobi 18V One+ Hand Vac
4.3
One review highlighted a 3-year limited tool warranty and a 3-year limited battery warranty (for the included pack), which is reassuring in this price class.
P2Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
No score yetTool-change simplicity
P1
Product 1: Ryobi 18V One+ Hand Vac
4.1
Because the nozzle accepts common 1-1/4 inch accessories, switching tools and adapting to different tight spots is relatively easy.
P2Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
No score yetUpholstery / Above-Floor Pickup
P1Product 1: Ryobi 18V One+ Hand Vac
No score yet
P2
Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
3.4
Above-floor cleaning is solid for crumbs and general spot cleaning on seats and cushions. Embedded hair or deep upholstery work is less convincing without a motorized brush.
Weight
P1
Product 1: Ryobi 18V One+ Hand Vac
3.4
Weight varies with the battery. One review measured about 3 lb 1.5 oz with a 2Ah pack, while a comparison using a 4Ah battery put it around 3.67 lb, which some users may find heavy for longer sessions.
P2
Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
4.6
Most reviewers emphasize how light it feels in hand, making short cleanups easy and reducing fatigue compared with heavier battery-platform handhelds.