Average score
P1
Product 1: DeWalt DCV517B 20V Max Cordless...
4.2
P2
Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
3.5
Accessories and Tools
P1
Product 1: DeWalt DCV517B 20V Max Cordless...
3.4
The built-in nozzle and integrated hose are widely seen as practical, and one roundup highlights a wide accessory selection. However, multiple reviewers note the bare tool ships without extra tips/brushes, and some users may need third-party kits or an adapter for standard attachments.
P2
Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
3.6
Accessories focus on everyday reach: an integrated crevice tool is repeatedly praised, and several reviews mention a small brush plus wet/dry pieces like a squeegee, along with a wall-mount charging base.
Assembly and Setup
P1
Product 1: DeWalt DCV517B 20V Max Cordless...
4.5
Setup is minimal: install a charged battery, confirm the tank and filter are seated, and start cleaning. Reviewers frame it as ready-to-use with little fuss.
P2
Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
4.6
Setup is quick, with reviewers describing it as essentially click-together and ready to use in about a minute, plus easy mounting of the charging base if desired.
Battery and Charging
P1
Product 1: DeWalt DCV517B 20V Max Cordless...
4.3
Battery performance is described as ample for typical cleanup sessions, with one test completing two vehicle interiors on a 4.0Ah pack with charge remaining. Compatibility with different DeWalt pack sizes is highlighted, but bare-tool buyers must supply their own battery/charger.
P2
Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
3.1
Charging is handled via a wall-mount base that reviewers find convenient, but recharge times can be long (hours). It works best as an always-on-the-dock grab-and-go tool.
Bin and Bag
P1
Product 1: DeWalt DCV517B 20V Max Cordless...
4.3
The 1/2-gallon tank and latch system are described as easy to remove, empty, and reattach, with sealing elements that help keep debris contained. Capacity is inherently small, so bigger messes may require more frequent emptying.
P2
Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
3.2
The bin is small and transparent for visibility, which helps for quick pickups but means more frequent emptying during bigger cleanups.
Build quality and durability
P1
Product 1: DeWalt DCV517B 20V Max Cordless...
4.3
Build quality feedback is mostly positive, citing sturdy latches, gaskets, and a durable hose that holds up to jobsite-style cleanup. Long-term impressions (including a one-year update) remain favorable.
P2Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
No score yetCarpet — Low-Pile Pickup
P1Product 1: DeWalt DCV517B 20V Max Cordless...
No score yet
P2
Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
3.1
On low-pile carpet and mats, performance ranges from adequate to struggling depending on the debris and how clean the filter is. Some testers report difficulty on fuzzy car carpeting and entry mats.
Clogging and debris prevention
P1
Product 1: DeWalt DCV517B 20V Max Cordless...
4.3
A tank flap/seal design is mentioned as helping keep debris from escaping if the vacuum tips over. No widespread clogging complaints appear, but the 1-1/4 inch intake naturally limits very large debris.
P2
Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
3.4
Clogging is not a frequent theme, but some testers report larger bits can wedge in the intake and that dirty filters quickly reduce airflow, which can feel like a clog.
Comparative performance
P1
Product 1: DeWalt DCV517B 20V Max Cordless...
3.5
Compared with larger corded or higher-capacity cordless vacs, it trades raw suction and capacity for portability and convenience. Several reviewers prefer it specifically because it reduces friction for small cleanup tasks.
P2Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
No score yetControls and UI
P1
Product 1: DeWalt DCV517B 20V Max Cordless...
4.4
Controls are simple, with a large on/off switch that is easy to hit while holding the handle. There are no complex modes or screens to manage.
P2
Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
2.8
Controls are simple but polarizing: multiple reviews note the trigger-style operation requires holding the button the entire time rather than using a constant-on switch.
Cordless convenience
P1
Product 1: DeWalt DCV517B 20V Max Cordless...
4.5
Cordless, grab-and-go cleanup is one of the most praised benefits, especially for cars, small shop messes, and remote spaces without outlets. Users like avoiding cords and dragging out full-size vacs.
P2
Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
4.3
Cordless convenience is a major upside: reviewers like being able to grab it quickly for crumbs and small messes without dealing with cords.
Crevice / Groove Pickup (Hard Floors)
P1
Product 1: DeWalt DCV517B 20V Max Cordless...
4.3
Crevice reach is a strength when using the pull-out hose, enabling cleaning between seats, corners, and grooves that the main nozzle cannot comfortably access.
P2
Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
3.1
Crevice work is helped by the integrated crevice tool. It can pull grit from tight seams, but reach and sealing in very tight spaces varies by tester and body shape can limit depth under low clearance.
Ease of use
P1
Product 1: DeWalt DCV517B 20V Max Cordless...
4.1
Day-to-day usability is praised for quick cleanups and one-handed operation, especially in cars and shops. A minority find the wide-nozzle grip awkward and prefer using the hose for better control.
P2
Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
3.8
Ease of use is generally good for quick jobs thanks to its light weight and simple design, but frequent filter cleaning and short runtime can interrupt longer tasks.
Edge and Baseboard Cleaning (Hard Floors)
P1
Product 1: DeWalt DCV517B 20V Max Cordless...
4.5
An angled head and hose-based approach are praised for guiding along baseboards and edges, helping clean fine debris that collects against walls.
P2Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
No score yetEmptying and Mess Control
P1Product 1: DeWalt DCV517B 20V Max Cordless...
No score yet
P2
Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
3.2
Emptying can be messy in practice: some debris sticks near the intake and several reviews describe having to remove the filter by hand. A comparative test also suggests it can hold onto collected sand well when powered off.
Filtration / Dust Containment
P1
Product 1: DeWalt DCV517B 20V Max Cordless...
4.4
Several reviews emphasize a washable HEPA wet/dry filter and strong dust containment for fine particles. Maintenance is framed as simple rinsing/tapping clean, though one reviewer cautions about managing the filter correctly for wet pickup.
P2
Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
3.3
Filtration is basic but washable. Reviewers say performance depends on keeping the filter and inserts clean; when they get gummed up, suction drops quickly.
Fresh Liquid Pickup Speed
P1
Product 1: DeWalt DCV517B 20V Max Cordless...
4.4
For small liquid spills, reviewers describe it as a convenient, fast solution compared with towels or larger vacs. There is limited evidence on large-volume liquid pickup, and users caution against expecting flood-level capability.
P2
Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
4.3
Thin liquid pickup is a strong point when using the wet/dry accessory, quickly removing puddles and many mixed spills. Very viscous messes like ketchup or honey may smear and need follow-up wiping.
Hard Floor — Fine Dust Pickup
P1Product 1: DeWalt DCV517B 20V Max Cordless...
No score yet
P2
Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
4.0
Fine dust pickup is reported as strong on hard surfaces in hands-on testing (for example flour and dust), though some budget-focused tests still note a lingering film that takes extra passes.
Hard Floor — Large Debris Intake
P1Product 1: DeWalt DCV517B 20V Max Cordless...
No score yet
P2
Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
3.8
Large debris pickup is generally good for a handheld, with reviewers successfully grabbing crumbs, cereal, and small yard debris, though very bulky pieces can get awkward at the nozzle.
Hose length
P1
Product 1: DeWalt DCV517B 20V Max Cordless...
4.2
The integrated hose is generally seen as long enough for car detailing and tight spots, with one review describing extension up to several feet. Some users may still prefer a longer hose for more reach without moving the unit.
P2Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
No score yetMaintenance requirements
P1
Product 1: DeWalt DCV517B 20V Max Cordless...
4.4
Maintenance is framed as easy: empty the tank, twist off the filter, and rinse or tap it clean. The washable filter reduces consumable waste and keeps upkeep simple.
P2
Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
2.6
Maintenance is regular and hands-on: expect frequent rinsing of the bin area and washing the filter/foam components, especially after wet pickups or fine dust.
Maneuverability and Handling
P1
Product 1: DeWalt DCV517B 20V Max Cordless...
3.8
Handling is generally described as light and well balanced, but some users find the main nozzle grip awkward and note the unit can feel heavier than smaller car vacs. Using the hose improves reach and control in tight areas.
P2Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
No score yetNoise level
P1
Product 1: DeWalt DCV517B 20V Max Cordless...
3.3
Noise is a recurring complaint, with at least one reviewer calling it loud compared with other vacs. A minority describe it as only moderately quiet, so overall expect a louder handheld experience.
P2
Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
1.8
Noise is a common complaint. Testers describe it as loud for a handheld, with measured readings in the mid-70 dB range in one review and around 90 dB in a comparative test.
Onboard tool storage
P1
Product 1: DeWalt DCV517B 20V Max Cordless...
4.3
Onboard storage of the hose and having a built-in nozzle reduce loose parts and make it easy to grab quickly. Multiple reviewers still wish DeWalt bundled additional tips (brush/crevice tools) in the box.
P2Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
No score yetOngoing ownership costs (bags, filters, batteries)
P1
Product 1: DeWalt DCV517B 20V Max Cordless...
3.4
Ongoing costs are modest for users with existing DeWalt batteries, but the bare-tool package can raise the effective price if you need to buy a battery and charger. Replacement filters are noted as readily available.
P2Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
No score yetOverall opinion
P1
Product 1: DeWalt DCV517B 20V Max Cordless...
4.9
Overall sentiment skews strongly positive, with multiple reviewers recommending it for quick cleanup and one reporting continued satisfaction after a year. A more critical review still acknowledges it performs on typical shop debris, just with limitations.
P2Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
No score yetPet-Ready Features
P1Product 1: DeWalt DCV517B 20V Max Cordless...
No score yet
P2
Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
2.8
Pet readiness is mixed: it can lift loose clumps of hair and some strands, but without a roller brush it is not a specialist tool for embedded pet hair on upholstery.
Price and Value
P1
Product 1: DeWalt DCV517B 20V Max Cordless...
3.8
Value is strongest for owners already invested in DeWalt 20V batteries, especially when the bare tool is priced under typical kit bundles. Some buyers question the cost once you factor in a separate battery/charger and add-on accessories.
P2
Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
4.2
Value is viewed positively because it is often priced in the budget range and still useful for frequent quick cleanups. The biggest value caveat is the short runtime and the need for frequent cleaning.
Runtime
P1Product 1: DeWalt DCV517B 20V Max Cordless...
No score yet
P2
Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
2.6
Runtime is short, commonly reported around 10–11 minutes, with some testers noticing reduced power near the end of the cycle.
Storage footprint and upright-stand stability
P1
Product 1: DeWalt DCV517B 20V Max Cordless...
4.5
Reviewers repeatedly call the unit compact and easy to store, including keeping it in a toolbox or car. Its small footprint supports grab-and-go use in tight workspaces.
P2
Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
4.5
Storage is a standout. The unit is compact, can live on its wall-mount dock, and is easy to stash in small homes, closets, or vehicles.
Suction and Airflow
P1
Product 1: DeWalt DCV517B 20V Max Cordless...
4.0
Most reviews describe strong pickup for small debris (dust, chips, car carpets), with some calling it surprisingly powerful. A consistent caveat is that it cannot match a larger shop vac’s suction and can struggle with bigger chunks unless you get very close.
P2
Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
3.4
Suction is a strength for quick debris and spot cleaning, but lab-style comparisons show lower lift than pricier tool-battery handhelds and performance can drop when filters clog. It tends to handle small debris well, while bigger items may require repositioning.
Suitability for heavy-duty use
P1
Product 1: DeWalt DCV517B 20V Max Cordless...
3.2
It performs best as a powerful mini for targeted messes, not as a primary shop vac or whole-jobsite solution. Reviews repeatedly position it as a supplement for quick, localized cleanup.
P2Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
No score yetSuitability for small spaces
P1
Product 1: DeWalt DCV517B 20V Max Cordless...
4.5
Its compact body and hose access make it well suited to cars, cabins, and tight shop corners where larger vacuums are annoying to deploy.
P2Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
No score yetTool-change simplicity
P1
Product 1: DeWalt DCV517B 20V Max Cordless...
4.1
Switching between the front nozzle and pull-out hose is generally quick and intuitive. One review notes the hose can be tricky to pull free if it is pushed in too tightly.
P2Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
No score yetUpholstery / Above-Floor Pickup
P1
Product 1: DeWalt DCV517B 20V Max Cordless...
4.4
Car seats and in-between upholstery areas are a common use case, and the hose makes above-floor pickup more practical than relying on the wide front nozzle alone.
P2
Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
3.4
Above-floor cleaning is solid for crumbs and general spot cleaning on seats and cushions. Embedded hair or deep upholstery work is less convincing without a motorized brush.
Versatility
P1
Product 1: DeWalt DCV517B 20V Max Cordless...
4.4
The wet/dry design plus dual pickup modes makes it useful for car detailing, edge cleanup, and small spills. Reviews still warn it is not intended for big jobsite cleanups or major water events.
P2Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
No score yetWeight
P1
Product 1: DeWalt DCV517B 20V Max Cordless...
4.3
Several reviews call it super light for a wet/dry handheld, while one roundup notes it can feel heavier than some competing car vacs. Most still consider the weight manageable given the convenience and power.
P2
Product 2: Black+Decker Dustbuster QuickClean
4.6
Most reviewers emphasize how light it feels in hand, making short cleanups easy and reducing fatigue compared with heavier battery-platform handhelds.