Average score
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
3.8
Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
4.2
activity auto-detection
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
4.5

Auto-detection reliably logs walks and runs, and reviewers said it kicked in well for walks, though auto-logged sessions carry less detail than manually started workouts.

Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
3.5

Auto-detection is mixed: one review reports recognition for 25 strength movements and 8 sports, while another explicitly notes missing automatic workout detection.

app ecosystem
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
4.2

Garmin Connect works across Android, iOS, and desktop, giving users a broad data view, though the overall ecosystem still depends heavily on the companion app experience.

Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
4.5

One reviewer highlights access to more than 400 apps, indicating a broader app catalog than the price suggests.

band quality
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
4.8

The new standard 14mm quick-release bands are a major upgrade, making straps easier to swap and more flexible than the old proprietary setup.

Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
No score yet
battery life
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
3.8

Battery life usually lands around four to five days, though heavier use and brighter settings can pull it closer to three days.

Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
4.4

Battery life is a recurring strength, with 12-day typical-use claims and real-world reports ranging from strong week-plus use to shorter endurance under heavier testing.

blood oxygen tracking
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
3.2

Pulse Ox and SpO2 tracking are available, but confidence in accuracy is mixed, with some reviewers warning the readings can be off.

Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
4.0

Blood oxygen monitoring is repeatedly listed among the watch’s core all-day health sensors.

Bluetooth connectivity
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
2.8

Phone pairing is easy, but Bluetooth support is limited for accessories such as headphones or gym equipment.

Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
4.0

Bluetooth phone linkage is supported for core smartwatch functions such as calls and syncing.

brightness
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
2.7

The display is readable, but reviewers repeatedly wanted more brightness.

Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
4.7

Screen brightness is praised across reviews, with multiple mentions of strong clarity and easy visibility in bright conditions.

build quality
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
4.6

The aluminum build is consistently described as a meaningful upgrade that feels more premium than the previous plastic case.

Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
4.5

Build quality is framed as premium for the price, with repeated mentions of stainless steel, sapphire protection, and a durable feel.

button controls
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
2.3

The lack of real side buttons and reliance on the pseudo-button setup make controls more awkward than on sportier Garmin watches.

Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
4.5

The four-button layout is consistently highlighted as a practical control advantage, especially during workouts or sweaty use.

call handling
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
3.0

Call and text actions exist, especially on Android, but iPhone limits and light interactivity keep call handling basic.

Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
4.0

Reviews describe wrist-based calling support over Bluetooth as part of the watch’s smart feature set.

calorie tracking usefulness
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
2.8

Calorie data is included, but one reviewer found burned-calorie estimates slightly off.

Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
No score yet
charging convenience
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
3.3

The clip-style proprietary charger is simple to use, but it is still a special cable users have to remember.

Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
No score yet
charging speed
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
3.0

Charging is acceptable but not fast; around an hour gets a substantial refill, yet multiple reviewers said it feels slow versus rivals.

Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
No score yet
coaching features
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
3.8

Coaching is fairly light, with useful alerts and nudges, but it stops well short of richer training guidance.

Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
4.5

Coaching features are a major selling point, with Zepp Coach, guided workouts, structured plans, and beginner-friendly training support mentioned across reviews.

comfort
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
4.9

Comfort is one of the Lily 2’s biggest strengths, with reviewers repeatedly saying it is easy to wear all day and through the night.

Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
4.5

Comfort is a strong point for everyday running use, with reviewers calling out the watch’s light feel and approachable presentation.

companion app quality
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
3.6

Garmin Connect is data-rich, but several reviewers found parts of it clunky or harder to navigate than they wanted.

Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
4.5

The Zepp companion app is generally well received for detail, clarity, and practical presentation of health and training data.

contactless payments
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
3.8

Garmin Pay is useful on Classic models when a bank is supported, but bank support limitations reduce its value for some buyers.

Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
3.8

Contactless payments are supported, though one review notes bank support can still be limited in some regions.

cross-platform compatibility
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
4.3

The Lily 2 works with both Android and iPhone, though feature parity is better on Android.

Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
3.8

Cross-platform support exists, but reviewers note smoother integration can vary by phone and some features are platform-specific.

customization options
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
4.2

Band swapping and some settings customization are strong, but watch-face and visual customization stay modest.

Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
4.5

Customization is supported through adjustable training plans and user-tailored screens or levels.

display quality
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
3.4

The grayscale display is clear enough and sometimes high-contrast, but many reviewers still found it basic compared with brighter AMOLED watches.

Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
4.5

Display quality earns consistent praise for a bright, sharp AMOLED presentation that looks more premium than the price suggests.

durability
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
4.4

The shift to aluminum was repeatedly framed as helping durability as well as appearance.

Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
4.5

Durability is supported mainly by sapphire-glass protection and repeated references to a robust, scratch-resistant build.

ECG functionality
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
1.0

Reviews explicitly note that ECG is not available on the Lily 2.

Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
No score yet
fit
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
4.8

The small, light case fits especially well on smaller wrists and is comfortable enough for overnight wear.

Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
4.5

Fit is positively described, with at least one reviewer specifically saying the watch fits very well on wrist.

fitness tracking accuracy
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
4.7

For casual exercise, reviewers consistently describe activity tracking as accurate.

Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
4.5

General fitness tracking is described as accurate in broad use, including positive feedback on activity tracking and gym performance.

GPS accuracy
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
3.7

Connected GPS is generally accurate when the phone is with you, but there is no onboard GPS and performance remains phone-dependent.

Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
3.8

GPS performance is usually described as good or accurate in typical conditions, but not class-leading for tougher trail or dense-cover scenarios.

health tracking accuracy
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
4.3

Core health metrics are generally described as reliable, even if specialized tracking is not top tier across the board.

Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
No score yet
heart rate accuracy
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
4.6

Heart-rate performance is a standout, staying close to reference devices in many workouts with only occasional misses.

Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
3.5

Heart-rate accuracy is mixed: some reviewers saw notable issues, while others found results much stronger or close to chest-strap readings.

materials quality
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
4.6

Materials earn mostly positive notes thanks to aluminum and premium finishing, though one review still wanted more upscale material choices.

Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
4.5

Materials quality stands out for the price thanks to repeated references to sapphire glass and stainless steel components.

menu navigation
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
3.9

Navigation is usable and sometimes intuitive, but reactions are mixed because some interactions feel less direct than on button-based Garmin watches.

Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
3.0

Menu navigation is functional but not fully streamlined, with one reviewer calling out extra steps to reach some mapping tools.

music controls
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
3.8

The watch can control music on a paired phone, covering basic playback control needs.

Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
4.0

Music controls are present as part of the everyday smartwatch feature set.

onboard music storage
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
1.0

There is no onboard music storage on the Lily 2.

Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
4.2

Onboard storage is a clear feature, with 4GB used for maps, playlists, podcasts, and other offline content.

operating system experience
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
2.6

Garmin’s proprietary software handles core tasks well enough, but the lack of native Google or Apple app support limits flexibility.

Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
4.0

The Zepp OS experience is presented as familiar and serviceable, with standard Amazfit behavior and features.

outdoor visibility
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
4.9

Outdoor readability is a clear strength, with reviewers praising visibility even in direct sun.

Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
4.8

Outdoor visibility is a strong suit, with reviewers specifically noting easy readability outdoors and in bright sun.

pairing reliability
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
4.6

Phone pairing and connected-GPS handoff were described as dependable and noticeably better than on the original Lily.

Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
4.5

Pairing appears straightforward, with at least one reviewer describing setup as quick and successful.

recovery insights
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
3.6

Body Battery offers useful readiness context, but richer recovery metrics such as formal recovery time are missing.

Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
4.5

Recovery insights are a repeated theme, including rest guidance, recovery indicators, and post-workout recovery estimates.

reliability
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
4.2

Overall day-to-day reliability is good for the basics, with accurate tracking and solid routine behavior outweighing some UI and display quirks.

Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
No score yet
safety features
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
4.7

Incident detection, LiveTrack, and emergency-contact alerts are strong additions and widely praised.

Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
No score yet
sleep tracking accuracy
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
3.6

Sleep tracking is useful and can be accurate, but several reviews found sleep timing or stage estimates inconsistent.

Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
5.0

Sleep tracking is one of the strongest-reviewed areas, with reviewers praising wake detection, detail, and overall accuracy.

smartphone notifications
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
3.5

Notifications arrive reliably, but customization and interaction are limited, especially on iPhone.

Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
4.0

Smartphone notifications are supported for calls, texts, and apps.

smartwatch features
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
3.3

Smartwatch tools cover the basics, yet most reviews describe the overall feature set as intentionally light.

Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
4.2

Smartwatch features are broad for the price, including maps, phone tools, health widgets, and navigation extras.

software smoothness
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
2.9

Software responsiveness is serviceable rather than polished, with reviewers mentioning laggier gestures and less fluid behavior than leading smartwatches.

Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
4.5

Software smoothness is positively described, with one reviewer noting little lag in day-to-day use.

step counting accuracy
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
4.5

Basic daily metrics such as steps are generally described as accurate and dependable.

Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
No score yet
stress tracking
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
4.7

Stress tracking is consistently praised and often singled out as one of the best wellness features.

Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
4.0

Stress tracking is included as part of the watch’s standard health-monitoring suite.

style and design
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
4.9

Style is a major selling point, with many reviews calling the Lily 2 elegant, subtle, and more jewelry-like than a typical smartwatch.

Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
4.2

Style and design get generally positive reactions for looks and premium feel, though at least one reviewer wanted more refined styling options.

third-party app support
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
3.8

Third-party support is mixed: workouts can sync to some external services, but there is no broad native app ecosystem on the watch itself.

Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
3.8

Third-party platform support is mixed overall: some reviews cite integrations like Strava or TrainingPeaks, while another notes missing links with some training apps.

touchscreen responsiveness
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
2.8

The touchscreen works, but slow responses and missed touches are among the most common complaints.

Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
4.5

Touch interaction appears responsive, with low-lag behavior noted during use.

user interface
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
3.5

The interface is understandable after some use, yet several reviewers still found it less natural than Garmin devices with real buttons.

Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
4.5

The user interface is generally described as clear, self-explanatory, and practical for beginners.

value for money
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
3.5

Value depends heavily on priorities; reviewers felt the design and wellness focus can justify the price, but feature shoppers may find stronger specs elsewhere.

Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
4.9

Value for money is one of the clearest strengths, with reviewers repeatedly calling the watch unusually capable and affordable for under $170.

voice assistant quality
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
No score yet
Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
4.0

Voice assistant support is present for commands and quick interactions, and reviewers treat it as a useful added smart feature.

watch face quality
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
2.8

Watch faces are functional but limited, with some reviewers wanting more color or variety.

Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
3.0

Watch face quality is the one design area with a clearer complaint, as one reviewer questioned the look of some faces.

water resistance
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
4.5

The 5ATM rating makes the Lily 2 fine for pool use, showering, and other everyday wet conditions.

Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
4.5

Water resistance is supported by repeated 5 ATM references and positioning for swimming or shower use.

wellness insights
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
4.6

Body Battery, sleep score, and related daily insights are among the most appreciated parts of the experience.

Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
4.5

Wellness insights go beyond raw metrics, with recurring praise for detailed sleep data, BioCharge, and readiness-style context.

Wi-Fi connectivity
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
No score yet
Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
2.0

Wi-Fi support looks limited, with one reviewer explicitly noting map transfers rely on Bluetooth instead of Wi-Fi.

workout tracking variety
Product 1: Garmin Lily 2
4.2

The 18 profiles cover many common activities, but omissions such as indoor cycling or some sports keep variety from feeling complete.

Product 2: Amazfit Active 3 Premium
4.8

Workout coverage is broad, with repeated mentions of hybrid training support, 170-plus sports modes, and many trackable activities.