Compare Apple AirPods Max vs Cambridge Audio Melomania P100 SE Headphones

aptX support was criticized as missing in the SoundGuys review.

aptX Lossless support is treated as part of the impressive specification.

EQ customization was a consistent weakness because reviewers wanted a real user EQ or disliked Apple removing choice through Adaptive EQ.

EQ customization is a major strength, with reviewers praising the seven-band EQ and how well the headphones respond to tuning.

Codec support was a recurring weakness because reviewers noted reliance on AAC/SBC and lack of higher-end Bluetooth codec support.

Codec support is praised through aptX Adaptive and aptX Lossless support, but wireless LDAC absence is a separate limitation.

The Smart Case was the clearest recurring complaint, with reviewers calling it ineffective, unprotective, pointless, or terrible.

The hard case is generally sturdy and solid, but its size hurts compactness.

Android compatibility was consistently weak because reviewers said Android and Windows users lose key smart features.

Android setup worked smoothly in the tested pairing flow, with the reviewer connecting quickly to a Samsung foldable device.

Launch and refresh feature evidence was negative, with reviewers calling the limited update disappointing and asking for fixes in a future generation.

Feature coverage is viewed positively, with reviewers noting modern ANC-headphone features and useful app-based controls.

Included accessories were criticized because reviewers wanted essential wired-use adapters or cables included at the price.

Included accessories are appreciated, especially the case and cable management touches.

Battery life was mixed to negative: some reviewers found it acceptable or impressive, but many called 20 hours weak versus competitors.

Battery life is one of the clearest strengths, repeatedly called excellent, incredible, extraordinary, or best-in-class.

Value for money was the biggest tradeoff: reviewers often liked the headphones but criticized the high price, especially against cheaper rivals.

Value is one of the strongest themes, with reviewers repeatedly calling the P100 SE well priced or exceptional for sound quality per dollar.

Spatial audio was one of the most praised software features, especially for movies, supported Apple content, Dolby Atmos, and head-tracked experiences.

Spatial audio is absent, which some reviewers list as a limitation, though others say the natural soundstage reduces the sting.

Clamping force drew criticism from reviewers who felt pressure from the clamp or sides of the head.

Clamping force is mostly acceptable or well judged, though one review found the fit snug compared with rivals.

One reviewer praised wind-noise reduction during calls, noting that callers could still hear the voice well.

Microphone noise reduction is weaker than some competitors, with one reviewer saying it does not filter as much background noise.

The integrated microphone was judged inconsistent, especially when paired with the wrong device.

Microphone quality is good in quiet conditions, but noise suppression is less impressive in background noise.

Wear detection and auto-pause were praised as simple and effective when used with supported devices.

Wear-detection auto play/pause mostly worked but showed a brief audio cutout in one hands-on test.

Wind-noise handling was praised in call or ANC microphone contexts, especially for white noise and outdoor calls.

Wind handling is mixed: one review criticized wind noise in transparency mode, while another found ANC outdoor wind handling very good.

Travel friendliness was limited by flight-ANC doubts, bulk, case issues, and the tendency to keep the headphones at home or in the studio.

Travel friendliness is mixed: battery life is excellent for long trips, but the large case and limited folding hurt portability.

Siri worked well for one reviewer, who preferred voice activation over manually using the crown.

Voice assistant access worked cleanly in hands-on testing.

The headphones can play loud, but one reviewer noted they do not get incredibly loud.

Volume output is mixed: some found it loud enough or very loud, while another wanted more Bluetooth/3.5mm loudness.

Portability and foldability were weak because reviewers noted bulk, lack of folding, and reluctance to carry them outside.

Portability is a weakness because the headphones and case are not especially compact.

Passive isolation was mixed, with some reviewers praising the seal and others finding it weaker than expected for certain head shapes.

Passive noise isolation is a notable strength, with reviewers praising how much noise is blocked before ANC.

Long-term durability evidence was mixed, with one reviewer reporting headband wear over years and another saying the headphones still looked new.

Durability is judged positively through solid materials and a reviewer description of the headphones as durable overall.

Transparency mode received unusually strong agreement, with reviewers repeatedly calling it natural, clear, best-in-class, or among the best they had heard.

Transparency mode ranges from natural and useful to merely acceptable and less airy than competitors.

One reviewer praised the minimalist, beautiful look, supporting a high aesthetics score.

Aesthetics split reviewers: some liked the clean design and blue color, while another found the wide look silly when worn.

Overall recommendations were positive but conditional: reviewers admired the sound, ANC, and Apple integration while warning about price, weight, case, and rival value.

Overall recommendations are very positive, especially for sound-first buyers and value seekers, with caveats around ANC, comfort, and bulk.

Several reviewers praised instrument separation and layering, but one technical review criticized image separation and fine detail as weak.

Detail retrieval and instrument separation are praised in both written and hands-on listening tests.

Frequency-response evidence was mixed: some reviewers found the tuning balanced or close to preference targets, while one considered it only acceptable.

Frequency-response impressions are mixed because the SE sounds warmer and less flat than the original, even though the tonal balance can be adjusted.

Smart listening features were useful and practical for some reviewers, but Adaptive EQ and related smart behavior also drew criticism for needing improvement.

Smart listening features such as DynamEQ are useful for low-volume listening but not universally preferred.

LDAC support was criticized as missing in the SoundGuys review.

LDAC is a clear omission for reviewers who expect high-res wireless codec support.

Water or sweat resistance was criticized because reviewers found the lack of protection a miss for a portable product.

Water resistance is a weakness because one reviewer warns users to be careful due to no rating.

Advanced software features were valuable for iOS users but mixed overall because reviewers also noted quirks, limited feature depth, or Apple-only behavior.

Advanced software features such as DynamEQ and app changes are useful but taste-dependent, with some reviewers liking the added energy and others preferring simpler original tuning.

Reviewers noted ANC can slightly change the sound, either by relieving pressure cleanly or by softening punch and dynamics.

ANC sound impact is similarly split, with TechRadar praising tonal consistency and RecordingNow hearing a more problematic change with ANC on.

ANC background noise level was praised as clean and natural, with little hiss or artificial pressure in reviewer comments.

Background noise reduction is viewed as improved and effective, but not the quietest in the class according to comparison-focused reviewers.

ANC was one of the strongest points across the review set, with most reviewers calling it excellent, top-tier, or best-in-class, though a few found newer rivals stronger in some scenarios.

ANC is generally judged good or improved, though not always elite; reviewers praised effectiveness while noting Sony/Bose-class options can still outperform it.

Weight comfort was the most divided comfort issue: some praised the distribution, while many called the headphones heavy or tiring over time.

Weight comfort is mixed to negative, with one reviewer calling it among the heaviest in class while another found it substantial but acceptable.

Bass was generally described as controlled, punchy, deep, and less boomy than some rivals, with the main criticism coming from reviewers who wanted more sub-bass or dynamics.

Bass earns strong praise for impact and EQ potential, but some reviewers found the SE tuning too bass-forward or not fully controlled.

Midrange clarity drew strong praise from several reviewers, especially for vocals, but one technical review found the mids somewhat muted and veiled.

Mids are frequently praised as clear, rounded, and strong with vocals or instruments.

Call microphone quality ranged from okay to good, with several reviewers finding it usable and one calling headset performance strong.

Microphone quality itself is good in quiet conditions, even if background noise filtering is less strong.

Immersive audio quality was praised for cinematic, surround-like experiences and convincing spatial effects.

Immersion is praised through wide, effortless soundstage comments, even without spatial audio.

One reviewer found the AirPods Max stayed clean at higher volumes with basically no distortion.

Clarity at higher volume is praised, with reviewers noting strong clarity and no distortion at raised levels.

Build quality was a major strength, with reviewers repeatedly praising metal materials, solid construction, durability, and premium assembly.

Build quality is consistently praised as sturdy, premium, or strong for the price, with only minor creaking noted in one review.

Physical controls were widely praised, especially the Digital Crown and button layout, which reviewers found tactile, smooth, intuitive, and easy to use.

Physical button controls are praised for usability and responsiveness.

USB-C was welcomed for lossless or low-latency wired use, though one reviewer still framed the refresh as disappointing because little else changed.

USB-C connectivity is positively mentioned as part of the wired-listening and cable package.

Ear cup padding was mostly praised for softness, breathability, depth, and replaceability, though one reviewer disliked the material preference.

Ear cup padding and space are generally praised for plushness, roominess, and comfort.

Treble was often described as crisp, clear, detailed, and non-fatiguing, though one technical review found the treble uneven and occasionally unpleasant.

Treble is often praised for detail, shine, and sparkle, but DynamEQ can make the sound more aggressive for some listeners.

Replaceable earpads were praised because reviewers found the magnetic pads easy to remove and replace.

Replaceable earpads and battery-related serviceability are repeatedly praised as longevity-friendly.

Latency was viewed positively when wired or in normal video use, with reviewers noting no video delay and a useful low-latency update.

Gaming/low-latency performance was judged snappy and suitable for videos and fast-paced games.

Design was praised as beautiful, minimal, and distinctively Apple.

Design is usually viewed positively, especially the clean lines and color options, although the look is not universally loved.

Headband padding and mesh were mixed, with one reviewer worried about long-term fabric wear and another finding it breathable and comfortable.

Headband padding is one of the more divisive comfort points, ranging from improved and comfortable to stiff or not meaningfully changed.

Premium feel was one of the strongest consensus positives, with reviewers emphasizing metal materials, luxury presentation, and high-quality feel.

Premium feel is praised through materials, finish, and comparisons to more expensive headphones.

Bluetooth reliability was viewed positively, with reviewers noting strong connection strength, no dropouts, and later updates improving connectivity issues.

Bluetooth-related experiences were largely positive where judged through pairing and multipoint behavior.

Comfort over long use was split: some reviewers found them extremely comfortable for hours, while others reported fatigue, clamp, heat, or long-session discomfort.

Comfort is mixed: some reviewers found it comfortable or improved, while others criticized weight, snugness, or headband pressure over time.

Reviewers broadly praised the AirPods Max sound as clear, refined, balanced, spacious, or even outstanding, though one audiophile-focused review found it merely competitive.

Sound quality is the strongest repeated praise, described as detailed, clear, engaging, and high value for the price.

Most reviewers found the soundstage wide or spacious for closed-back wireless ANC headphones, while one technical review considered it only slightly above average.

Soundstage is generally wide and spacious, though one reviewer heard it as more intimate than wide.

One reviewer singled out the hinge design as rock solid and highly durable.

Hinge feel and arm construction are praised for tightness, friction, and premium movement.

3.5mm analog input availability was a recurring complaint because reviewers wanted the cable or adapter included and found the lack inconvenient.

ANC's effect on the sound signature is mixed: one review praised the lack of tonal shift, while another found ANC-on tuning messier on the SE.

The app is widely praised for EQ, controls, and clean layout, though one reviewer wanted clearer EQ frequency labeling.

Auto on/off reliability was a repeated frustration because reviewers disliked the lack of a real power button and dependence on the case.

RecordingNow gave the product a strong S-Tier expert score, reflecting award-style recognition in that review.

USB-C lossless and low-latency audio was viewed as a useful update for wired editing or production use.

Cable quality receives a positive note for the included USB-C and 3.5mm cables.

Channel matching or imaging was criticized in one technical review, which found image separation and distinction poor.

Charging convenience was mixed, with one long-term reviewer linking battery preservation to the case and still finding charging part of the convenience problem.

Wired listening options are appreciated as part of the broader connectivity package.

Dolby Atmos and head tracking were praised as accurate, cinematic, and especially good for movies and supported content.

Ear cup rotation is judged useful and flexible where reviewed.

One reviewer heard slight creaking during movement, but described it as minor.

Apple ecosystem integration was strongly praised for seamless pairing, easy device switching, and daily-use convenience.

Headband adjustability was not evaluated directly beyond factual mechanism mentions.

Multi-platform compatibility was limited; reviewers emphasized that non-Apple users miss many unique features.

Multipoint generally works, but switching can require pausing and there is no automatic switching in one test.

Preset and DynamEQ-style tuning are useful but taste-dependent; some presets are usable while DynamEQ can be divisive.

Replaceable components receive praise where reviewers focus on the user-replaceable battery as a long-term ownership benefit.

Sensor performance is mostly positive through wear-detection testing, though resume behavior had a minor glitch in one review.

Sidetone/voice passthrough needs improvement according to one reviewer who wanted clearer, louder self-voice feedback.

Smart Pause works quickly in hands-on testing, though one reviewer observed a brief audio glitch when resuming.

The off-white finish receives a small positive note for resisting a dirty-looking appearance over time.

Setup and software are generally smooth, clean, and intuitive, with fast firmware and app interactions noted.

Sound leakage evidence was mixed, with one reviewer saying leakage was low and another saying people nearby could hear at higher volumes.

One reviewer reported strong Bluetooth stability, including no dropouts while moving away from the source device.

Sustainability and repairability are praised thanks to recyclable packaging, recycled materials, user-replaceable batteries, and removable pads.

Sustainability materials earn praise from TechRadar, especially the recycled plastic and driver material claims.

Voice prompts stand out positively, especially the Matt Berry/Southwark option.

Wear-detection auto-pause is fast, though the broader wear-detection behavior was not flawless.

Wear detection performed quickly but had a resume-side glitch that the reviewer wanted fixed.