Average score
Product 1: Kwikset Obsidian Smart Lock
3.1
Product 2: Aqara U50 Smart Lock
4.0
Access logs
Product 1: Kwikset Obsidian Smart Lock
3.8

Access history is available in some setups (and was highlighted in early coverage), but in practice it can depend on the hub and platform, and not every controller app exposes detailed logs.

Product 2: Aqara U50 Smart Lock
4.3

Access logs are a meaningful benefit in several reviews, showing event history and helping track who unlocked when, with retention commonly described in the weeks-to-month range.

Alarm/siren loudness (if included)
Product 1: Kwikset Obsidian Smart Lock
1.0

Reviews note no built-in alarm/siren, so there is no siren loudness benefit to rely on.

Product 2: Aqara U50 Smart Lock
3.7

The lock provides audible prompts and alarms, and some reviews like the adjustable volume options; others find default voice volume loud or note that certain door-open alarms can be inconsistent.

App
Product 1: Kwikset Obsidian Smart Lock
2.6

App support is inconsistent: some versions rely on a smart-home hub app rather than a dedicated Kwikset app, which can limit advanced controls like remote code creation on certain platforms.

Product 2: Aqara U50 Smart Lock
4.3

The Aqara app is described as feature-rich for user management, logs, automations, and settings; a recurring complaint is that some controls (like sounds/volume) may require pairing to an Aqara hub.

Auto-lock
Product 1: Kwikset Obsidian Smart Lock
4.1

Auto-relock/auto-lock features are commonly praised for convenience and worked consistently in testing, but toggling settings may require opening the interior panel and using small switches.

Product 2: Aqara U50 Smart Lock
4.3

Auto-lock features are frequently praised, including timed auto-lock and door-closed-based locking; reviewers also like modes that temporarily bypass auto-lock for high-traffic situations.

Auto-relock after failed attempts
Product 1: Kwikset Obsidian Smart Lock
No score yet
Product 2: Aqara U50 Smart Lock
4.2

Failed-attempt protections are discussed as a plus, with temporary keypad lockouts after repeated wrong codes and continued access via key or app for admins.

Backset compatibility
Product 1: Kwikset Obsidian Smart Lock
No score yet
Product 2: Aqara U50 Smart Lock
4.5

Reviewed setups commonly mention support for the two typical US backset depths, which helps it work with most standard doors.

Battery
Product 1: Kwikset Obsidian Smart Lock
3.2

Powered by four AA batteries with low-battery warnings and external 9V jump terminals for emergencies; battery life reports vary (some cite roughly 5 to 6 months), and battery access can require partial disassembly.

Product 2: Aqara U50 Smart Lock
4.2

Battery life is commonly positioned as months on four AA cells, with USB-C emergency power as a safety net; several reviewers report better battery behavior than early U100 units.

Bluetooth
Product 1: Kwikset Obsidian Smart Lock
1.0

Multiple reviews explicitly note there is no Bluetooth, so there is no phone-proximity unlock or key fob option.

Product 2: Aqara U50 Smart Lock
3.5

Bluetooth is central for HomeKey/HomeKit-style setups and works well up close, but it is also the main source of perceived latency or flakiness in remote-style control when a hub is not handling communication.

Build quality and durability
Product 1: Kwikset Obsidian Smart Lock
3.5

The exterior build is described as sturdy and the mechanism proved reliable in use, but at least one reviewer reported sloppy bolt machining that made installation harder.

Product 2: Aqara U50 Smart Lock
4.1

Build quality is widely seen as solid (heavy feel, good materials), with the main complaints being a bulky footprint and a few plastic parts or covers that may feel less premium over time.

Door-sense
Product 1: Kwikset Obsidian Smart Lock
2.3

Reviews note no full door-open/closed alerting, but some describe auto-lock behavior that only triggers when the door is closed and may beep when it is not fully shut.

Product 2: Aqara U50 Smart Lock
4.0

Door status sensing is a standout feature thanks to the built-in gyroscope approach, though at least one review finds it less reliable than a dedicated door sensor in tricky installs.

Door compatibility (deadbolt fit)
Product 1: Kwikset Obsidian Smart Lock
No score yet
Product 2: Aqara U50 Smart Lock
4.3

Multiple strike/bolt plate options help the lock fit many common deadbolt cutouts, but proper alignment matters to avoid binding or abnormal bolt behavior.

Existing hardware reuse
Product 1: Kwikset Obsidian Smart Lock
4.5

If you are replacing another Kwikset deadbolt, the footprint and standard door prep can make swaps easier, with minimal changes to the door.

Product 2: Aqara U50 Smart Lock
4.2

Several reviewers highlight rekeyability to match existing keys as a major convenience, though installation still replaces the deadbolt hardware and some users reuse or swap strike components depending on fit.

Feature additions via updates
Product 1: Kwikset Obsidian Smart Lock
3.5

Z-Wave Plus versions cite over-the-air firmware update capability, but overall functionality remains intentionally minimalist and still depends on the hub ecosystem.

Product 2: Aqara U50 Smart Lock
4.2

At least one review notes that Aqara has expanded passcode controls over time (more granular periodic schedules), suggesting ongoing firmware and app improvements.

Fingerprint
Product 1: Kwikset Obsidian Smart Lock
No score yet
Product 2: Aqara U50 Smart Lock
1.0

Multiple sources emphasize the lack of a fingerprint reader as the main feature loss versus the U100, which is a dealbreaker for users who rely on biometric entry.

Finish durability
Product 1: Kwikset Obsidian Smart Lock
No score yet
Product 2: Aqara U50 Smart Lock
3.9

The matte black finish is praised for hiding fingerprints and looking modern, but limited color options and bulky styling are recurring nitpicks.

Guest Codes and Access
Product 1: Kwikset Obsidian Smart Lock
3.4

Obsidian stores up to 16 codes on the standalone model and up to 30 codes on connected versions, with 4 to 8 digits per code; code limits and scheduling features vary by model and ecosystem.

Product 2: Aqara U50 Smart Lock
4.6

Passcode features are repeatedly highlighted, including multiple household codes, guest sharing, one-time use codes, and scheduled codes for regular visitors; some setups enforce longer minimum PIN lengths.

Hub requirement
Product 1: Kwikset Obsidian Smart Lock
2.3

Most smart features require a compatible Z-Wave hub; without it, Obsidian behaves like a standalone keypad deadbolt.

Product 2: Aqara U50 Smart Lock
3.5

A hub is frequently recommended to unlock full functionality (broader integrations, Matter bridging, richer automations), but adds cost and can introduce placement or connectivity considerations.

Installation and Setup
Product 1: Kwikset Obsidian Smart Lock
3.5

Many reviewers found setup straightforward with good hardware options, but others ran into alignment issues, confusing instructions, or a tricky handing/calibration step that required rework.

Product 2: Aqara U50 Smart Lock
4.3

Installation is generally described as quick and straightforward for standard single-cylinder deadbolts, with app-led calibration; a few reviews note instructions can be picture-heavy or require minor door/strike adjustments.

Jam detection
Product 1: Kwikset Obsidian Smart Lock
No score yet
Product 2: Aqara U50 Smart Lock
4.2

Some reviews describe abnormal bolt or door-not-closed situations triggering alerts, helping users catch a misaligned door or failed latch/bolt extension.

Key override reliability
Product 1: Kwikset Obsidian Smart Lock
1.0

Obsidian is keywayless, so there is no physical key override if electronics fail; the emergency fallback is the external 9V jump terminals plus your PIN.

Product 2: Aqara U50 Smart Lock
4.3

Mechanical key backup is consistently included and the hidden keyhole cover is appreciated for aesthetics and casual security, with reviewers generally treating it as a dependable fallback.

Keypad
Product 1: Kwikset Obsidian Smart Lock
4.0

The illuminated touchscreen keypad is central to the design and is generally responsive and easy to use, though a few reviewers note it can take multiple touches to wake.

Product 2: Aqara U50 Smart Lock
4.4

The keypad is widely liked for large, backlit digits and reliable code entry, but it typically needs a wake touch first and some users want the first press to register immediately.

Keyway quality
Product 1: Kwikset Obsidian Smart Lock
No score yet
Product 2: Aqara U50 Smart Lock
4.3

Keyway and cylinder design are often framed positively because the lock can be rekeyed; one reviewer cautions that cylinder swaps can be non-standard and may have constraints.

Lock/unlock speed
Product 1: Kwikset Obsidian Smart Lock
3.5

Unlocking is generally quick once the keypad wakes, but some reviewers reported slower wake behavior and slightly slower operation in hot, sunny conditions.

Product 2: Aqara U50 Smart Lock
4.4

HomeKey taps and keypad entry are usually described as fast, and the motor action feels smooth once the door is aligned; app-based commands can be slower when Bluetooth is involved.

Locking motor
Product 1: Kwikset Obsidian Smart Lock
2.8

Motor noise is noticeable to some reviewers, who describe the mechanism as loud during operation.

Product 2: Aqara U50 Smart Lock
4.3

Lock operation is repeatedly described as smooth and quiet when aligned correctly, with less risk of grinding compared with poorly fitted smart locks.

Locking reliability
Product 1: Kwikset Obsidian Smart Lock
4.3

Across reviews, the lock generally operated consistently without jamming, and the auto-relock feature performed reliably when enabled.

Product 2: Aqara U50 Smart Lock
4.2

Overall locking reliability is viewed as strong in daily use, including remembering codes and auto-lock behavior even when hub connectivity is imperfect, provided the door and strike are properly aligned.

Notifications
Product 1: Kwikset Obsidian Smart Lock
3.3

The lock provides audio/LED indicators (including low-battery alerts) and hub apps can show lock state, but native, lock-specific push notifications are limited and platform-dependent.

Product 2: Aqara U50 Smart Lock
4.1

Notifications and alerts are commonly used for status awareness (locked/unlocked, abnormal events, and user activity), with some reviews highlighting customizable alert behavior.

Physical attack resistance
Product 1: Kwikset Obsidian Smart Lock
3.7

Removing the keyway reduces exposure to key-based attacks, but otherwise Obsidian is a standard deadbolt without advanced intrusion sensing or active defense features.

Product 2: Aqara U50 Smart Lock
3.7

Physical security is generally treated as appropriate for typical homes, with the hidden keyhole design adding a small deterrent and overall construction seen as sturdy.

Pick/drill resistance (if rated)
Product 1: Kwikset Obsidian Smart Lock
4.0

Keywayless entry reduces the risk of traditional picking and bump-key attacks; reviews do not provide an explicit drill-resistance rating.

Product 2: Aqara U50 Smart Lock
3.6

One review references residential-grade security positioning and acknowledges that higher pick/drill resistance usually requires spending more, framing U50 as adequate rather than high-security.

Remote access
Product 1: Kwikset Obsidian Smart Lock
3.1

When paired to a Z-Wave hub, reviewers were able to lock/unlock and check status remotely, but code management and other functions can be restricted by the chosen platform.

Product 2: Aqara U50 Smart Lock
3.8

Remote control is generally available through smart-home ecosystems or hubs, and checking lock status is valued for peace of mind; performance varies, with Bluetooth-based paths sometimes feeling slower than hub-based control.

Security features (encryption)
Product 1: Kwikset Obsidian Smart Lock
4.1

SecureScreen (decoy/random digits) helps prevent fingerprint-based code guessing, and Z-Wave versions mention encryption; the keywayless design also removes common key-based attack vectors like bump keys.

Product 2: Aqara U50 Smart Lock
4.4

Security is framed around modern app and platform controls, with some reviews explicitly calling out AES-style encryption and secure ecosystem integrations.

Smart-home integration (Alexa, Google, Siri, HomeKit, Matter, Thread)
Product 1: Kwikset Obsidian Smart Lock
3.3

Integration centers on Z-Wave hubs (such as SmartThings, Wink, and Control4) with Alexa/Google voice control typically routed through that hub; multiple reviews call out missing native HomeKit support.

Product 2: Aqara U50 Smart Lock
4.4

Integration is repeatedly cited as a strength, especially Apple HomeKey and Apple Home support; broader platform support (Google, Alexa, Matter/SmartThings) is often possible but typically depends on using an Aqara hub or compatible controller.

Touchscreen
Product 1: Kwikset Obsidian Smart Lock
4.0

The glossy, minimalist touch surface looks premium on modern doors but can smudge; SecureScreen and anti-fingerprint coatings help reduce obvious fingerprint trails.

Product 2: Aqara U50 Smart Lock
4.4

The touch interface is generally responsive and easy to use, with minor learning curve around waking the panel before entering a code.

User access management
Product 1: Kwikset Obsidian Smart Lock
2.9

You can add/remove PINs and use an optional master code, but advanced guest access controls (expiring or scheduled codes) are limited or unavailable on some models and hubs.

Product 2: Aqara U50 Smart Lock
4.6

User access management is a strong point, with support for multiple users, one-time codes, scheduled or periodic access, and code-specific automations in the Aqara ecosystem.

Value and Price
Product 1: Kwikset Obsidian Smart Lock
3.2

Pricing is mid-to-premium for a touchscreen deadbolt; value is better if you already own a Z-Wave hub, but paying extra for a hub and living with limited code controls can reduce perceived value.

Product 2: Aqara U50 Smart Lock
4.5

Value is a major theme: most reviews call U50 one of the most affordable HomeKey-capable options, though the need for an additional hub to unlock full functionality can reduce the perceived bargain.

Voice control
Product 1: Kwikset Obsidian Smart Lock
3.2

Voice control generally works for locking and status checks through Alexa/Google when paired with a hub, but unlocking by voice is often restricted for security.

Product 2: Aqara U50 Smart Lock
3.9

Voice control is supported through major platforms, but often requires a hub integration and may be gated by platform security steps such as PIN requirements for unlocking.

Warranty and support
Product 1: Kwikset Obsidian Smart Lock
No score yet
Product 2: Aqara U50 Smart Lock
2.8

Support and warranty considerations come up mainly around modifications: at least one review warns that swapping the lock cylinder can void warranty and puts the user on their own.

Weather resistance
Product 1: Kwikset Obsidian Smart Lock
2.4

The black exterior can absorb heat in direct sun; at least one reviewer noted it can get hot to the touch and may slow slightly under high heat.

Product 2: Aqara U50 Smart Lock
3.9

Weather protection is generally presented as suitable for outdoor exposure, but the exact IP rating varies across reviews (often IPX5; one source claims higher) and one review notes reduced dustproofing versus pricier models.

Wi-Fi
Product 1: Kwikset Obsidian Smart Lock
1.1

There is no built-in Wi-Fi; remote access typically depends on Z-Wave plus a hub rather than direct Wi-Fi connectivity.

Product 2: Aqara U50 Smart Lock
3.0

Most U50-focused reviews say there is no built-in Wi-Fi and that Wi-Fi-style remote/integration features depend on hubs; one included video appears to cover a different Aqara lock with built-in Wi-Fi, which can confuse expectations.