Bottom Line
Choose these for detail-first sound and strong ANC. Skip them if you want heavier bass or better value at $299.
Best for
Detail-focused listeners who care more about clarity, separation, hi-res codec support, and comfort than about bass slam. They also suit buyers who want strong ANC without giving up a more audiophile-leaning presentation.
Not for
Bassheads, bargain hunters, and anyone wanting a no-fuss all-rounder. Several reviews say the price is high, the low-end can feel light, and the battery is only average.
Verdict
The NeoBuds Planar succeed where many premium earbuds do not: they sound genuinely distinctive. Across the reviews, the strongest through-line is exceptional detail, separation, codec support, and a comfortable fit, with ANC that ranges from good to surprisingly strong. The tradeoff is just as consistent: bass weight is polarizing, the battery is only average for the price, and several reviewers felt the $299 asking price was hard to justify. If your priority is airy, precise, hi-res wireless sound with lots of customization, these make sense. If you want a more universal crowd-pleaser with bigger low-end punch or stronger value, the recommendation gets much harder.
Pros
-
Codec support is a major strength, with repeated praise for the unusually broad hi-res codec list.
-
Reviews note Bluetooth 5.4 support and solid wireless basics.
-
Multiple reviews explicitly mention a six-mic or three-per-side microphone setup.
-
LDAC support is repeatedly confirmed across reviews.
-
USB-C charging is explicitly confirmed in multiple reviews.
-
aptX family support is explicitly confirmed, including aptX Adaptive.
-
Reviews repeatedly confirm hi-res playback support, though they focus on playback capability rather than DAC specifics.
-
With the right tip size, reviewers report an excellent seal and secure fit.
-
Lossless support is explicitly cited through aptX Lossless and related hi-res codec support.
-
Android setup is straightforward, with Android recognition and Fast Pair both mentioned.
-
Instrument separation and layering are a standout, with reviewers repeatedly calling the presentation clean and highly detailed.
-
Multiple reviews confirm a wide ear-tip selection, typically spanning extra small through extra large.
-
Reviews confirm a generous bundle that can include multiple ear tips, a charging cable, manuals, and a pouch or carrying case.
-
Squeeze, pinch, and pressure controls are often described as deliberate and more reliable than typical touch inputs.
-
The ConneX app is widely described as useful and feature-rich, even if not every reviewer liked its look or behavior.
-
Charging is a clear strength thanks to wireless support and quick top-ups.
-
Where tested, video and gaming latency are described positively, with low-latency use called fine or strong.
-
Treble clarity is a recurring strength, with reviewers highlighting clean, precise highs and strong upper-frequency detail.
-
Reviews describe straightforward use across Apple devices and Android, suggesting broad everyday compatibility.
-
Several reviews note customizable case lighting with multiple color options.
-
One review confirms a find-my feature that makes the earbuds beep when misplaced.
-
One review calls the case very pocketable and easy to carry.
-
One review says the matte case finish helps prevent fingerprints.
-
One review says native voice assistant commands are acted on swiftly.
-
One review notes the 5.6g weight keeps them from feeling heavy.
-
Reviews repeatedly praise the NeoBuds Planar for detailed, high-fidelity sound, though one review found the tuning inconsistent from track to track.
-
Fit security is generally good, including for workouts and movement.
-
Multiple reviews describe an open, spacious presentation with a large soundstage.
-
Comfort is consistently strong, with several reviewers saying they could wear the earbuds for hours or all day.
-
ANC is widely described as effective or better than expected, though most reviewers stop short of calling it class-leading.
-
Presets such as Dynamic or Electrostatic are often useful, with reviewers finding modes that better suit their tastes.
-
Reviews cite IP54 or IP55 protection for sweat, dust, and light weather exposure.
-
One review says the tuning stays reasonably close to the Harman curve.
-
Call quality ranges from decent to very good, with clear pickup in good conditions but not universal best-in-class performance.
-
Multipoint support is present and often works well, though some reviews report occasional sluggish or manual switching.
-
One review says the earbuds provide decent passive isolation with a proper fit.
-
Build quality gets mixed-to-positive feedback, with some reviews calling the buds well-made and others criticizing cheap-looking materials.
-
Midrange performance is generally clear and natural, but one review says vocals can dip back in the mix on some material.
-
Setup and pairing are often easy, but one review notes awkward app behavior across devices.
-
Controls are generally usable, but responsiveness and refinement are not universally praised.
-
The EQ offers real customization, but several reviews say it is limited, technical, or less effective than expected.
-
Transparency mode is usable and sometimes helpful, but most feedback stops short of calling it natural or fully open-sounding.
-
Wear detection and other onboard sensors are present, but wear-detection behavior is not consistently praised.
Cons
-
Bass is the main dividing line: several reviews hear limited punch or body, while others report strong or satisfying bass once fit or tuning is dialed in.
-
Design is divisive: some reviewers call the earbuds modern or futuristic, while others simply do not like the look.
-
Volume output is usable but not exceptional, with some reviewers saying the buds are not especially loud.
-
Microphone noise reduction is mixed: some reviewers hear background suppression struggle, while others say it helps keep calls usable outdoors.
-
Case impressions are mixed, ranging from ugly or cheap-looking to robust and well-made.
-
Battery life is usually judged average or mediocre for the price, though some reviews report acceptable day-to-day runtime.
-
Value is the main weakness, with frequent pushback on the $299 price even from reviewers who liked the sound.
-
One review explicitly says the presentation has width but lacks depth.
-
One review explicitly notes that spatial audio is not included.
FAQ
Are the Edifier NeoBuds Planar bass-heavy?
Usually not. Bass is the most divisive part of the tuning: several reviews call it light or lacking punch, while others got stronger bass once they found the right fit or EQ.
How good is the ANC?
ANC is generally a strength. Multiple reviews say it is effective or better than expected, though most stop short of calling it the absolute best in the category.
Are they a good fit for Android users?
Yes. Reviews mention straightforward Android recognition, Google Fast Pair, and broad codec support that especially benefits Android listeners.
Are they worth $299?
That depends on your priorities. Reviewers who loved the detail and codec support still frequently questioned the price, so value looks strongest for buyers specifically chasing this kind of sound.
Reviews we analyzed
Video Reviews
Article Reviews
Best Earbud Headphones
#1
4.3
Choose Sony WF-1000XM6 for top-tier noise canceling and a spacious, punchy sound; Skip if you struggle with foam-tip comfort/fit or want the most...
Pros: USB-C, LDAC, Codec support, Smudge resistance, Soundstage width, Active noise cancellation effectiveness, Sound quality
Cons: None
#2
4.3
Choose JBL Tour Pro 3 for feature-hungry listeners who want a smart-case transmitter and lively sound. Skip if you need the smallest, most...
Pros: Dongle, Codec support, Ear tip size options, Equalizer customization, LDAC, Android compatibility, Carry case quality
Cons: None
#3
4.3
Choose for top-tier sound and a feature-rich, future-proof codec stack; Skip if you prioritize the very best ANC or consistently clean calls in...
Pros: Codec support, aptX, Sensors, Build quality, Sound quality, Soundstage width, Bass performance
Cons: Spatial audio, Find My
#4
4.2
Choose Nothing Ear (a) if you want standout design, very good sound, and easy daily comfort for under $100. Skip it if you...
Pros: Comfort during long use, Software/setup simplicity, LDAC, Multi-platform compatibility, Design and Aesthetics, Noise cancellation adjustability, Instrument separation
Cons: none